- Joined
- Oct 24, 2003
- Messages
- 21,731
- Reaction score
- 2,622
Kind of a weird analogy, no?
The whole original point of the "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" meme was that it's something that's impossible to do. It is literally impossible to pull yourself up by your bootstraps. It was a joke to talk about something that is impossible to do. In the context of wealth accumulation, it's a joke to believe that by working a bunch of jobs, you're going to become a millionaire or billionaire. It's literally impossible.
That's not really the case with physical exercise and body composition, is it? It's not literally impossible to get in good shape. It's not literally impossible to reduce your body fat. It's cheap and doesn't require a single dollar.
Becoming a billionaire =/= walking more and eating less?
It’s a great analogy because both conflate willpower with environment and what you start the race with.
When for some people 80% of weight loss is controlled by genetics, when the majority of calories are burned through sedentary metabolism, when many solutions prescribed cause the body to take countervailing actions, it is very much like bootstraps. Bootstraps are not impossible when poor people do become rich on occasion (not billionaires but middle class). It’s just a statistical rarity when you look at differences in resources, ability, and environment. That’s why it’s a dumb solution as it will never solve anything, it’s a cope out. Now take an obese person with crap genetics who also is living in poverty, the eat less/walk more solution is just as meaningless.
And FWIW I’m a bit of an ectomorph, no issues losing weight for me.