• Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.

Media Update from Johnny Walker: will not retire

There’s no reason why he should retire, legitimately, if overeem can get knocked out like 20 plus times in his k1 and mma career without people screaming for him to retire then a guy who has been chinny his entire career can do whatever the F he wants
 
There’s no reason why he should retire, legitimately, if overeem can get knocked out like 20 plus times in his k1 and mma career without people screaming for him to retire then a guy who has been chinny his entire career can do whatever the F he wants

It really varies from person to person, this isn't a safe statement. Some guys get rocked hard in sparring once, have concussion symptoms for months and just retire all the time. I think they've been studying the genetics behind CTE and onset dementia etc from head trauma and it looks like there's genetic precursors for some people and others, not so much. Regardless I think with guys like Tony Ferguson and Bigfoot we are literally going to see Chris Benoit type stories in a decade or two from now and feel really bad. Phil Baroni might have already been one of them.

Look what happened to Gerald McClellan. Just takes one bad night. I'm not saying Johnny Walker should retire but I'd love to know how many times he's been floored in sparring and...if you have a fighter with such a bad chin and loose defense that's been KOd 6 times by 32...as a coach maybe it's time to have an ethical conversation.
 
It really varies from person to person, this isn't a safe statement. Some guys get rocked hard in sparring once, have concussion symptoms for months and just retire all the time. I think they've been studying the genetics behind CTE and onset dementia etc from head trauma and it looks like there's genetic precursors for some people and others, not so much. Regardless I think with guys like Tony Ferguson and Bigfoot we are literally going to see Chris Benoit type stories in a decade or two from now and feel really bad. Phil Baroni might have already been one of them.

Look what happened to Gerald McClellan. Just takes one bad night. I'm not saying Johnny Walker should retire but I'd love to know how many times he's been floored in sparring and...if you have a fighter with such a bad chin and loose defense that's been KOd 6 times by 32...as a coach maybe it's time to have an ethical conversation.

CTE can be managed with lifestyle interventions but the people with CTE are often too uneducated or lacking in resources to be able to effectively manage it.
 
He for sure is going to have CTE at some point.

He has been short circuited so many times, and this latest one was a full shadface coma up against the fence. He was out for a good while.
I wonder what's worse for CTE getting knocked out often with pretty much single blows (Overeem/Walker) or being unable to get knocked out & take more punishment (Tony Ferguson/ Diaz bros, etc) :eek:
 
No signs of CTE lol.

Effects of CTE start to show much later. Fighters are often warned to be vigilant for a decade post retirement.

If you don't have any effects of CTE by that time, you are generally safe.
 
I wonder what's worse for CTE getting knocked out often with pretty much single blows (Overeem/Walker) or being unable to get knocked out & take more punishment (Tony Ferguson/ Diaz bros, etc) :eek:
The latter.

Most brain trauma comes from sparring. Especially sparring in headgear. Constant smaller hits for years are much more damaging long term than a single, big hit that puts the lights out.

However, when your lights start to go out often, like with Walker, its generally a sign that the brain has already endured too much and shuts everything down ASAP as a last ditch effort to protect you.

Most of the guys with bad CTE issues from MMA had great chins for most of their careers and weren't really known for being knocked out.

Chuck Liddell, Spencer Fisher, Nam Phan, Benson Henderson sounds like he might be in the early stages too.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,259,753
Messages
56,985,991
Members
175,486
Latest member
DaCrippler
Back
Top