Opinion Transgender Megathread V1.

Are trans-women women?

  • Yes

  • No

Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Fb-GFRma-WIAA5-WLM.jpg
 
Diogenes of Sinope said:
did I say that? Hes the pioneer in the gender construct ideology and gender theory.

Transgenderism itself is real disorder, obviously
Click to expand...
The problem isn't that you don't understand gender(which you don't). The problem isn't even that you don't want to understand it(no one can force you to learn).

The problem is that you think you understand it and spread misinformation based on that flawed understanding.

I will say that naming yourself after la philosopher while at the same time having no intellectual curiosity or critical thinking skills is a bold choice.
 
IamStryker said:
So you moved from attacking his character to attacking his credentials. Maybe try calling him ugly next?
Click to expand...
He doesn't have any credentials. That's the point. I'm not giving "one of the religious right's most influential young voices any fucking clicks, get it? I'm not watching the fucking video and adding to his revenue stream, understand? If you have relevant empirical data to support your stance, post it like @EndlessCritic. Talk is cheap.

So yeah, again, he's a youtube rando with no relevant credentials that we know of. Thanks for playing, please try again.
 
sangreporsangre said:
Click to expand...

100% agree. All the mewling and venting of spleens about transgender people is clear effort to pick out specific anecdotes and blow them up in social media until they're in a frenzy of manufactured outrage, then try to paint the entire concept with the same brush and call it a leftist conspiracy. It's a gross tactic but it works and it's a great way to whip up the base without having any policies that the people in general would support without the need for all that.

It's exactly the same thing with CRT, voter ID, masks, vaccines, and so on and so on. Such and such a very specific situation (real or made up, they don't care)is such an absolute outrage so everything remotely related to it is for sure also bad, particularly if there are Democrats who support any aspect of it. It's sad that it works time and time again, but there it is.
 
Ares Black said:
The problem isn't that you don't understand gender(which you don't). The problem isn't even that you don't want to understand it(no one can force you to learn).

The problem is that you think you understand it and spread misinformation based on that flawed understanding.

I will say that naming yourself after la philosopher while at the same time having no intellectual curiosity or critical thinking skills is a bold choice.
Click to expand...
lol another poster and I have already debunked your bizarre claims with sources.
 
Ares Black said:
This is a profoundly dishonest post.

John Money coined the term gender identity, but transgender people have existed for as long as people have existed. Decades before Money coined the term, the phenomenon of gender dysphoria and sex-change were studied.

John Money was also an quack whose experiments were unethical and immoral. The Reimer case is shocking and criminal IMO. It also, at its core, has nothing to do with transgender people. The child in question was not transgender.

Transphobes love to pretend that the work of John Money is what spawned the ideology of today, when in fact it's only one(very dark) chapter in the evolution of the understanding of gender.
Click to expand...
This is a profoundly dishonest post.

He did not claim in his post that trans people did not exist before John Money came along. John Money is important here because he came up with a lot of the gender theory BS that is parroted by leftists today. No pretending necessary. It's an unfortunate fact and labeling everyone critical of gender theory "transphobes" won't change it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ares Black said:
The problem isn't that you don't understand gender(which you don't). The problem isn't even that you don't want to understand it(no one can force you to learn).

The problem is that you think you understand it and spread misinformation based on that flawed understanding.

I will say that naming yourself after la philosopher while at the same time having no intellectual curiosity or critical thinking skills is a bold choice.
Click to expand...
I love how you all act like gender is some hard concept for conservatives to understand. It's not. It's just really boring and it baffles us that not only do you think it's so great but you use the idea so inconsistently. It's a convoluted mess. When someone critical asks you to define the word woman you can't even do that.
 
Lubaolong said:
Considering sexual orientation and gender identity is at least in part genetic, I would guess higher than average? What there is however no substantial evidence for is social or parental influence, which I'm sure is what you were trying to suggest.
Click to expand...

There is absolutely no evidence gender identity is in any way genetic. Where are you pulling that nonsense from that it is?

You'd have to be an extremely low IQ individual to believe parental influence doesn't play a part in gender identity.
When you have 2 parents who can't even decide what gender they want to be then what chance does the kid have?
 
King Joffery said:
There is absolutely no evidence gender identity is in any way genetic. Where are you pulling that nonsense from that it is?

You'd have to be an extremely low IQ individual to believe parental influence doesn't play a part in gender identity.
When you have 2 parents who can't even decide what gender they want to be what chance does the kid have?
Click to expand...
literally every leftist proposal to a solution is untested
 
Andy Capp said:
He doesn't have any credentials. That's the point. I'm not giving "one of the religious right's most influential young voices any fucking clicks, get it? I'm not watching the fucking video and adding to his revenue stream, understand? If you have relevant empirical data to support your stance, post it like @EndlessCritic. Talk is cheap.

So yeah, again, he's a youtube rando with no relevant credentials that we know of. Thanks for playing, please try again.
Click to expand...

You are a rando so by your logic I shouldn't give anything you say the time of day.

If you were good faith here you would have watched the video and seen that Walsh called out your source for using a completely bogus statistic on the number of intersex people. Instead of counting only real intersex people it came up with a competely dishonest criteria to inflate the numbers. They created their own criteria for the ideal man and woman and anything that deviated from it went into their lie on how many intersex people there are.

What kind of credentials do you need to find lies? Anyway since you won't look at my links I'll stop looking at the dumb shit you link.
 
King Joffery said:
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/ar...odel-Noella-McMaher-10-set-make-millions.html

2 trans parents raise a 'theybie' who turns out trans, what are the odds?
Click to expand...

What's funny is if a racist couple raise a racist child, we're told it's nurture not nature. Racism can be eliminated if we stop racists raising children to see the world through their own racist lens.

However, here, that same logic doesn't count.

Some people are born trans. I accept that. I also accept that some people are born psychos and no matter how much they are nurtured they can't change......Ted Bundy for example.

But most of the time, it's nurture. 9/10 serial killers had horrific upbringings resulting in them becoming horrific human beings.

This trans stuff is very rarely organic. It's a social contagion.
 
Andy Capp said:
100% agree. All the mewling and venting of spleens about transgender people is clear effort to pick out specific anecdotes and blow them up in social media until they're in a frenzy of manufactured outrage, then try to paint the entire concept with the same brush and call it a leftist conspiracy. It's a gross tactic but it works and it's a great way to whip up the base without having any policies that the people in general would support without the need for all that.

It's exactly the same thing with CRT, voter ID, masks, vaccines, and so on and so on. Such and such a very specific situation (real or made up, they don't care)is such an absolute outrage so everything remotely related to it is for sure also bad, particularly if there are Democrats who support any aspect of it. It's sad that it works time and time again, but there it is.
Click to expand...
Pure nonsense. I guess I'm just misremembering when my child was forced to wear a mask at school and became addicted to it to where I would pick her up from the playground and she would still be wearing it outside?

I'm misremembering how at my workplace I have now seen two teenagers switch back and forth on their gender identity. I have been required to use they/them pronouns at work as well.

I wasn't required to get a vaccine that I never needed right? But these topics are just made up fear mongering right?
 
IamStryker said:
You are a rando so by your logic I shouldn't give anything you say the time of day.

If you were good faith here you would have watched the video and seen that Walsh called out your source for using a completely bogus statistic on the number of intersex people. Instead of counting only real intersex people it came up with a competely dishonest criteria to inflate the numbers. They created their own criteria for the ideal man and woman and anything that deviated from it went into their lie on how many intersex people there are.

What kind of credentials do you need to find lies? Anyway since you won't look at my links I'll stop looking at the dumb shit you link.
Click to expand...
If he is right, that information is documented somewhere. Go get it and let me see. Until then your description of what he said isn't worth a fuck any more than that video. I don't give clicks to "religious right" grifters so you can fuck off if you don't like it. If what he said has any validity he'll have told you in the video where he got his information and you can go get it for me if you want to try to prove what he said is true. Until then, it's no different than "You shall not replace us".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,275,134
Messages
57,970,012
Members
175,884
Latest member
cloudfair

Share this page

Back
Top