NFL Top 20 NFL QB's

[Madmick]

Top 8 all clearly belong in the Top 10. Doesn't really matter how you order them.

Big Ben, Philip Rivers, and Russell Wilson over Elway & Young is kinda giving me a bit of reflux.

 

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

Top 8 all clearly belong in the Top 10. Doesn't really matter how you order them.

Big Ben, Philip Rivers, and Russell Wilson over Elway & Young is kinda giving me a bit of reflux.

Top 8 all clearly belong in the Top 10. Doesn't really matter how you order them.

Big Ben, Philip Rivers, and Russell Wilson over Elway & Young is kinda giving me a bit of reflux.Big Ben

Big Ben, Rivers and Wilson far better numbers than both Elway and Young.

 

[Madmick]

Big Ben, Rivers and Wilson far better numbers than both Elway and Young.

I don't care.

Almost certainly not if one adjusts for comparative generational production. That has already been pointed out to you in other threads. But even then, I wouldn't care.

 

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

I don't care.

Almost certainly not if one adjusts for comparative generational production. That has already been pointed out to you in other threads. But even then, I wouldn't care.

Trust me I get all that I also go with having seen them all play.

Rivers is number 6 in TD passes, 6 in yards, all his numbers are superir to Eway/Young. Rivers a far better passer,

Both Big Ben and Wilson dwarf what Elway/Young put up, both were better QB's just that simple, Both played vs far better defenses.

All this.....back in the day.....stuff gets trumped because of the fact defenses got a lot better as time went on. There are high school's today with bigger offenses lines than the 60's Packers. HS kids that would smoke Jesse Owens,

Time machine Derrick Henry back to 1970, it would be man vs boys, actually comical.

 

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

Jalen Milroe that Bama QB ran a sizzlin' 4.37 at his pro day, that is ultra fast for a QB.

But, not sure I;d want a QB that fast, knowing he has speed will he take off more than he should and with .....velocity,,,,the hits hurt more.

I know Vick ran a 4.2 something, he seemed to make it work.

 

[Sir Elzio Dennick]

Notice how we never see......

Tom Brady isn't the QB GOAT, it's really.................

So if not Brady then who, it will be someone with less of everything.