My gut reaction is to go w/ Title.
I did a lot of research in this forum before buying some sparring gloves recently, and it seems like Everlast never comes up for glove recommendations. Their Protex stuff seems to be the only products that stick out in my mind as getting any positive feedback, but I think the price is ridiculous, considering it's fucking Everlast.
I will admit, though, that I am heavily biased because I bought 2 pairs of their gloves from Sports Authority that started showing wear and tear in under 6 months. Unfortunately, I'm not knowledgeable on specific differences between the 2 brands.