I started watching mma right around the first season of TUF, but I didn't like or watch TUF. I remember watching APEX events shown late night on cable TV. I saw Jon Fitch vs Jeff Joslin and Ivan menjivar vs Ryan Ackerman and I was absolutely hooked. That led me to discovering sherdog, which led me yo discovering pride.
....
I somehow found a way to watch fedor vs crocop and almost couldn't believe what I was seeing. They didn't look human. They were so powerful and quick, it was like watching grizzly bears with precise technique.
And watching it again decades later, it's still incredible. You're right. That was the golden era of mma. Partly because there was still such a range of specializations. You had cro cop, the surgical kickboxer and also big nog, who would certainly strangle anybody with enough time. Seeing the contrast of styles back then was way more exciting.
.....
Great post, and I agree - that era will be looked back as the golden era of a rapidly-maturing sport, perhaps similar to how the
1920s-30s of boxing is viewed by historians as the fastest ascent from
fringe to mainstream popularity in the sport's history, moving from banned or underground to recognized sanctioning and popular acceptance.
Footage was so difficult to find back then, which was part of the allure - the hunt for good fight footage - and this was before Youtube and there were only a few nascent online video streaming or repository sites. Often downloads from torrents or other P2P methods. Sherdog used to have gems of compilations like
Hayato Sakurai that even in 240p looked otherworldly.
Finding old K-1 footage of Cro Cop over twenty years ago on a dial-up modem was my window into fights beyond the UFC and that's what hooked me. Slower dissemination of news meant you could watch fights that happened the month prior and still not know of the outcome. Less people who followed the sport I think made the community closer. Nothing wrong with casuals, but if somebody was following cards back then, you knew you were speaking with an enthusiast that could match your appreciation of the sport. Plus an asymmetry of knowledge meant techniques were siloed - the blending of discrete martial arts into a generic MMA may have evolved the sport as a whole, but I think eroded the mystique and intrigue of matches. "Styles make fights" holds true. Plus as the documentary "
Fighting in the Age of Loneliness" astutely pointed out, the consolidation of organizations, rulesets, sponsors, etc. has blunted the unique personalities of fighters, siphoned money away from fighters to a select few owners and coupled with an overabundance of events, greatly reduced the "must-watch" factor for fans.
I'd argue by catering to mass-appeal audiences, and decisions to merge with WWE to form a multi-billion publicly traded company, etc., has led to the alienation of their earlier fans (consumer-base?) and will long-term lead to a stagnation and perhaps decline in interest in the sport itself. TKO Group Holdings Inc, has created a larger addressable market of fans, but each average fan participation is now reduced to a surface, cursory level. The owners will not care, as this has no doubt been analyzed to be more short-term profitable.
It's an interesting consideration roughly 30 years on from the first burst of MMA with Semaphore's UFC 1 - what if TUF hadn't aired? Would the UFC have fizzled, and how would the landscape of martial arts look today without the TUF boom? Dream Stage Entertainment's entanglement with the Yakuza and PRIDE FC's downfall would have still occurred independently of UFC. Without the lightning in the bottle of TUF, it's possible this sport would have remained in the dark ages of post-NHB, pre-TUF. I don't think this is a better scenario, but it's certainly a different sport.
Also back to your post, Fitch-Joslin is an
all-time robbery of a decision (link to fight). I've never understood a) why Fitch wasn't deducted for a headbutt and b) the ref granting Fitch an injury time-out because he got rocked. Probably for the best - I understand Joslin has gone on to become a very well-respected and successful BJJ gym owner in Canada. There's a whole life after fighting. Thanks for reading.