• Xenforo is upgrading us to version 2.3.7 on Tuesday Aug 19, 2025 at 01:00 AM BST (date has been pushed). This upgrade includes several security fixes among other improvements. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

STAR WARS: THE FORCE AWAKENS Official Thread v.6

Status
Not open for further replies.
Movies for broad audiences and kids ruin everything. The best movies are R rated hands down or 'racist/sexist' like the old top classic films made before the 1950's.

Only good kid movies are animated and made by disney basically. But I feel every time they try to make it so 'widely' appealing it f#cks things up. Its STAR WARS how is a kid friendly 'strong young woman' realistic or even relevant?
Yeah, TFA is kid-friendly by being only the 2nd Star Wars to be rated PG-13. How is Rey kid friendly? Does that make Luke kid-friendly as well? For fuck's sake, Chewbacca isn't kid friendly?

It really seems like most of you are reaching to find anything to criticize this film. I guess that's what happens when something great is released, the narcissistic hipsters come out of the woodwork to try and seem like they know what 'real film-making' is.
 
It's pretty mediocre, honestly. Some people are ranking it above Return of the Jedi and I've even seen a few rank it above A New Hope. lol Realistically it's about the same level of Revenge of the Sith. I'll have to give it some time to decide which one of those is better. The fact that The Force Awakens is brand new may distort my judgement of it might make me think it's better. I need to see it a couple of more times.
 
It's a fucking starwars movie , what the hell people expecting gore and shitty edgy nolan batman characters GTFO
 
Listened to the Beatles the other day , they suck. No double kick and the guitars aren't even downtuned, Lennon can't even growl. Totally ghey
 
DarthVader was a black guy -No one complained.

Lando was a Black guy (and an awesome character) -no one complained.

Mace Windu was a black guy (and the GOAT even over Yoda) -no one complained.

I think you're reaching for people not liking a film to be racist for some reason. Which is kind of your own racism showing up here.
this
 
More dumbshit analysis by the greatest arm-chair critics on the internet. Seriously, a poster actually criticizing the film for having a female lead?

The criticisms in the OP are so outrageously dumb and clueless it's hardly worth an argument.

you are spewing out opinion without even reading my post. i never criticized film for having female lead. read and reflect before you knee-jerk.
 
In many ways it's a bigger flop than the prequels, at least for SW fans. It wasn't made for us, and the fact that they are pretending that this isn't a straight up reboot of a New Hope is insulting.
 
It really seems like most of you are reaching to find anything to criticize this film. I guess that's what happens when something great is released, the narcissistic hipsters come out of the woodwork to try and seem like they know what 'real film-making' is.

Hey bro, guess what? John Wick is massively overrated.
 
It's pretty mediocre, honestly. Some people are ranking it above Return of the Jedi and I've even seen a few rank it above A New Hope. lol Realistically it's about the same level of Revenge of the Sith. I'll have to give it some time to decide which one of those is better. The fact that The Force Awakens is brand new may distort my judgement of it might make me think it's better. I need to see it a couple of more times.
i swear to god if you put me in a jail cell and gave me a choice between Phantom menace and force awakens to watch, i would pick the former
 
you are spewing out opinion without even reading my post. i never criticized film for having female lead. read and reflect before you knee-jerk.

I read your post and it's tripe. I didn't say you did, I said a poster, referring to one of the first posts in this thread.
In many ways it's a bigger flop than the prequels, at least for SW fans. It wasn't made for us, and the fact that they are pretending that this isn't a straight up reboot of a New Hope is insulting.
It isn't a reboot because there are plenty of elements in TFA that differs from A New Hope. As I said before, the only big similarity is the superweapon. The fact that you are saying it's as big of a flop as the prequels just exposes the fact that you are looking to do nothing more than go against the grain. That actually goes for anyone saying that it's a reboot.
 
I agree about Finn he shouldnt even be in the movie its all for pc crowd and as dumb as he is then able to use a lightsaber is beyond pathetic. Id beat the shit out of little JJ Abrams for ruining star wars just to push his pathetic agenda.

The post definitely cements Sherdog as one of the worst forums on the internet.
 
Many elements of the film were fresh along with the backstories and character development of the new leads. Rey is nothing like Luke in terms of personality and if anything it's foretelling who her family may be.

How is it any different? Did you even watch the film? And since when was this film supposed to be some explanation about the Force? You know there are 6 other films in the series, right?

What a piss poor analysis. Just bitching and bitching.




Desert planets aren't out of the norm in the Star Wars universe lol are you fucking kidding me right? This is how I know you are just bitching just for the hell of it.

So if something isn't out of the norm in the Galaxy you can re-use the same setting in the same way in the same acts as previous films and it's fresh. Ok fanboy.

Young protagonist left on desert planet meets cute republic droid who just escaped the empire and calls them to action. Yea real original use of this setting and character development. Never seen it before.


Then protagonist meets reluctant hero partner and they must escape the empire in the falcon, can they fix it in time?


Han (sub Finn this time around) has to grapple with the choice to run or stay and fight. protagonist realizes they have force powers as republic realizes the spin off empire has a death star.

Protagonist joins republic battle to blow up Death Star. They fly a single x wing into its weak section. Boom. Bad Jedi escapes. Who could have guessed how that would have gone down.

Yep there are a few new characters and good back stories I appreciated but not enough to make up the constant re-hashing.


The droid didn't have a hologram of a Jedi, it was holding a missing part to the map in which to find Luke.

Whoa a map instead. The hologram was a little different. That makes this plot device totally unique and imaginative storytelling. Good call.

The First Order is an offshoot of the Galactic Empire lol we've known this before the film was released and it's pretty evident by the technology they use and the use of Stormtroopers. This isn't a Death Star considering the Death Star was an artificially made superweapon that destroys planets while the new superweapon was made from a planet and destroyed entire systems. It was a marked improvement from the originally Death Star, which aligns perfectly with the notion that The First Order/Snoke/Kylo Ren have a hard on for the Empire and Vader.

An off-shoot that coincidentally has the exact same power balance with the republic the empire did in 4-6 even after decades of battles, the republic blowing up multiple death stars and saving the Galaxy a few times. It's like everything that happened in 4-6 didn't mean anything as other posters said. Republic is still a rag tag group, first order although just an offshoot of the crumbled empire seems to have the same power over the Galaxy and republic the empire did before, reasons for this not explained well...yawn.

And lol at this Death Star being a creative idea different then the previous. Looked the same, blew up stuff pretty much the same, got blown up EXACTLY the same way. When they are making a battle plan the even show them side by side and they are totally similar besides size. Ask someone who hasn't seen the film what they think happens with this weapon and they could tell you. It was bigger yea, bigger waste of 3rd act screen time. Just a weak way to get all the characters to the fight. You really find this creative writing?


 
Funny how you come in here and it looks like its a terrible movie by the comments. Then you see reviews and talk to real people and its the complete opposite. So either people in here are angry at life, or people in real life are just 1000x dumber.
 
I read your post and it's tripe. I didn't say you did, I said a poster, referring to one of the first posts in this thread.

It isn't a reboot because there are plenty of elements in TFA that differs from A New Hope. As I said before, the only big similarity is the superweapon. The fact that you are saying it's as big of a flop as the prequels just exposes the fact that you are looking to do nothing more than go against the grain. That actually goes for anyone saying that it's a reboot.

Just the super weapon the same?

So a cute droid doesn't escape the empire in the first act and find our deserted protagonist on a desert planet and call them to action in both a new hope and force awakens first acts.

So the heros don't use the falcon to barely escape the baddies in both second acts while one hero character struggles with the decision to fight or run?

So the power balance between empire and republic and the first order and republic aren't very similar in both films although they are decades and many battles apart?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top