- Joined
- Jun 3, 2009
- Messages
- 85,187
- Reaction score
- 18,959
Update: July 20, 2016
Dragonlord's Review of STAR TREK BEYOND (No Spoilers)
Bottom Line: Less frenetic and more lighthearted than its predecessor, Star Trek Beyond is a pleasant, passable entry in the franchise.
While on a rescue mission, the Enterprise is attacked by a new enemy with an unstoppable swarm of ships. Forced to abandon the Enterprise, the crew is stranded on a planet where they uncover a new threat to the existence of the United Federation.
Fast & Furious director Justin Lin takes over the directing duties from J.J. Abrams while Simon Pegg does double duty playing Scotty and co-writing the script with Doug Jung. The result is a less frenetic and more lighthearted entry that allows more breathing room for camaraderie moments while providing enough satisfactory action sequences. Lin does a commendable job overall but some of his execution was lacking like the lackluster prison rescue scene.
Most of the Starship Enterprise core crew gets some quality screen time except for Sulu and Uhura who are mostly relegated in the prisoner role. Brooding that he’s one year older than his father will ever be, Kirk is more mature and considers being promoted to Vice-Admiral. Spock receives some bad news and contemplates leaving the Starfleet. Chekov gets a lot of screen time, albeit not very memorable, following Kirk around. Bones is paired up with Spock and have some amusing buddy moments. Scotty as always is the welcomed comic relief.
Unrecognizable under heavy latex makeup, Idris Elba plays the film’s main villain, Krall. Elba is wasted on Krall, who is like a Khan clone and spends most of his time searching for the MacGuffin artifact that powers his doomsday weapon. The revelation of his true identity comes way too late.
With her spunky attitude, striking yet alluring facial features, survival skills and impressive hand-to-hand fighting prowess, Jaylah (played by Kingsman breakout star Sofia Boutella) is probably the standout among the characters. There is just this one scene that bugs me though where she was soundly beaten up by her opponent but she turns the table around after her battle cry.
Here’s a few mishmash of thoughts. The massive spaceport Yorktown is a spectacular sight to behold. It’s like the space habitat in Elysium meets Inception and multiplied by ten. The swarm looks cool but the practicality and feasibility are questionable (see spoilers below). The photograph near the end was very poignant and packs the biggest emotional punch of the film.
Overall, Star Trek Beyond is a decent, enjoyable adventure paying homage to the original TV series but foiled with a Khan-like clone for a villain and a third act that rehashes the previous two Star Trek films.
Rating: 6.5/10
WARNING: SPOILER THOUGHTS AND MUSINGS BELOW.
* The third act is where the film loses me as it feels like a rehash of the previous two Star Trek film - villain on his way to a Federation planet/base, the heroes have to catch up to him, villain’s ship is neutered, villain gets inside the base, hero chases villain on foot and eventually fight him one-on-one.
* They looked cool and all but there were some aspects of the swarm that kinda bothered me. It didn’t really affect the quality of the film, mind you. The swarm’s primary offense is to ram themselves to their targets. Sure, the tips of the swarm ships were pointy but it doesn’t mean they’re indestructible.
* When you see the swarm in full force, it looks like they’re composed of a million small ships. These ships are not robot drones but are piloted by two beings as proven by Spock and Bones when they twice got onboard these ships by random. That means that there should be roughly 2 million soldiers piloting these ships. But back in Krall’s camp, you only see a handful of them. Plus, Krall’s base doesn’t look like it can accommodate a thousand people, let alone a million.
* The Deus Ex Machina plot device that destroyed the swarm was super convenient. Still don’t understand how come they just spontaneously combusted when the music was only meant to jam their communications and coordination.
* Kirk not finishing off or neutralizing Krall after shooting him when he had the chance was facepalm worthy.
Dragonlord's Review of STAR TREK BEYOND (No Spoilers)
Bottom Line: Less frenetic and more lighthearted than its predecessor, Star Trek Beyond is a pleasant, passable entry in the franchise.
![55MDZPs.jpg](https://i.imgur.com/55MDZPs.jpg)
While on a rescue mission, the Enterprise is attacked by a new enemy with an unstoppable swarm of ships. Forced to abandon the Enterprise, the crew is stranded on a planet where they uncover a new threat to the existence of the United Federation.
Fast & Furious director Justin Lin takes over the directing duties from J.J. Abrams while Simon Pegg does double duty playing Scotty and co-writing the script with Doug Jung. The result is a less frenetic and more lighthearted entry that allows more breathing room for camaraderie moments while providing enough satisfactory action sequences. Lin does a commendable job overall but some of his execution was lacking like the lackluster prison rescue scene.
Most of the Starship Enterprise core crew gets some quality screen time except for Sulu and Uhura who are mostly relegated in the prisoner role. Brooding that he’s one year older than his father will ever be, Kirk is more mature and considers being promoted to Vice-Admiral. Spock receives some bad news and contemplates leaving the Starfleet. Chekov gets a lot of screen time, albeit not very memorable, following Kirk around. Bones is paired up with Spock and have some amusing buddy moments. Scotty as always is the welcomed comic relief.
Unrecognizable under heavy latex makeup, Idris Elba plays the film’s main villain, Krall. Elba is wasted on Krall, who is like a Khan clone and spends most of his time searching for the MacGuffin artifact that powers his doomsday weapon. The revelation of his true identity comes way too late.
With her spunky attitude, striking yet alluring facial features, survival skills and impressive hand-to-hand fighting prowess, Jaylah (played by Kingsman breakout star Sofia Boutella) is probably the standout among the characters. There is just this one scene that bugs me though where she was soundly beaten up by her opponent but she turns the table around after her battle cry.
Here’s a few mishmash of thoughts. The massive spaceport Yorktown is a spectacular sight to behold. It’s like the space habitat in Elysium meets Inception and multiplied by ten. The swarm looks cool but the practicality and feasibility are questionable (see spoilers below). The photograph near the end was very poignant and packs the biggest emotional punch of the film.
Overall, Star Trek Beyond is a decent, enjoyable adventure paying homage to the original TV series but foiled with a Khan-like clone for a villain and a third act that rehashes the previous two Star Trek films.
Rating: 6.5/10
WARNING: SPOILER THOUGHTS AND MUSINGS BELOW.
* The third act is where the film loses me as it feels like a rehash of the previous two Star Trek film - villain on his way to a Federation planet/base, the heroes have to catch up to him, villain’s ship is neutered, villain gets inside the base, hero chases villain on foot and eventually fight him one-on-one.
* They looked cool and all but there were some aspects of the swarm that kinda bothered me. It didn’t really affect the quality of the film, mind you. The swarm’s primary offense is to ram themselves to their targets. Sure, the tips of the swarm ships were pointy but it doesn’t mean they’re indestructible.
* When you see the swarm in full force, it looks like they’re composed of a million small ships. These ships are not robot drones but are piloted by two beings as proven by Spock and Bones when they twice got onboard these ships by random. That means that there should be roughly 2 million soldiers piloting these ships. But back in Krall’s camp, you only see a handful of them. Plus, Krall’s base doesn’t look like it can accommodate a thousand people, let alone a million.
* The Deus Ex Machina plot device that destroyed the swarm was super convenient. Still don’t understand how come they just spontaneously combusted when the music was only meant to jam their communications and coordination.
* Kirk not finishing off or neutralizing Krall after shooting him when he had the chance was facepalm worthy.
Last edited: