Well, assuming all their character traits come with them I’ll have to go with Marie even though she is physically the least attractive of the three.
Marie is at the very least loyal to her husband/family and overall trustworthy despite her personal defects like being a thief and a gossip. Plus she isn’t “unattractive”. She’s pretty enough.
Skyler is a fickle malcontent who will cheat on you and kick you out of the house one second, help you clean your money the next second, and then act like a prisoner and make a huge pity spectacle of herself the second after that. No thanks. I’d rather deal with the traditional nagging but stability of Marie.
Lydia could have you whacked by Nazi’s on some neurotic whim. She’s the type who would never truly love you even though I find her the most attractive of the three