SHERDOG MOVIE CLUB: Let's Pick the Week 126 Movie!

Let's pick the week 127 Movie


  • Total voters
    18
  • Poll closed .
It was pretty damn staggering as a kid. These days the twist is spoiled on every dvd/bd cover not to mention the prequels.

Yea I can't even understand when you have a movie with a twist why they would place that hint on the cover of the DVD. Old or not, that's ridiculous and the person who approved it should get missile kicked.

th
3igx6Ty.gif
 
I found The Visit way more impressive. When I watched that, I was honestly thinking, "Oh, shit, Shyamalan is finally living up to his promise." You want genuine tension, genuine creepiness, and a fantastic wrap-up that doesn't lose/betray what'd been built leading up to it? The Visit has that shit locked down.
Yeah, it got really demented and sick towards the end. Btw, Shyamalan has said, that he wants to make movies he can share with his kids, so maybe he'll keep upping the ante in the future too as the kids get older.

The Village and The Visit are my top two, but I'd probably have Unbreakable in the #3 spot rather than Signs.
I loved Unbreakable, but for me it does not have that much rewatchability once you know the story. Mel Gibson is always good in loonie roles while Willis has been pretty meh for 20 years or so.
 
Inception, right? yeah, I know what you mean, man.

giphy.gif


have you seen Once Upon a Time in Anatolia? if not, I highly recommend it if you have a hankering for some immaculate night shots & brilliant lighting.

Never even heard of it. But if it's got a "Once Upon a Time in" title, then it's got some big shoes to fill. And no, I'm not talking about Robert Rodriguez' shoes.

Angel Heart has been nominated once or twice already, these troglodytes won't vote it in.

giphy.gif


One of the GOAT. I've seen it at least a dozen times and still whenever I watch it it gets better. Great premise, great writing, great characters, great performances, great atmosphere, great tension, great cinematography, great music. Everything in that movie is top-notch. And that'd be a hell of a lot of fun to watch and talk about in here.

Yeah, it got really demented and sick towards the end.

Oh, yeah. That poor germaphobe :eek:

I loved Unbreakable, but for me it does not have that much rewatchability once you know the story.

Interesting. I'm the other way. The first time I watched it, since it's Shyamalan, I think I was just waiting for the twist. Once I knew everything, watching it again allowed me to really appreciate the story and the characters a lot more.

Mel Gibson is always good in loonie roles

Can't deny that :D

giphy.gif


tenor.gif


Martin Riggs is one of my favorite characters ever.

while Willis has been pretty meh for 20 years or so.

Meh? You're not a fan of The Siege, The Whole Nine Yards/The Whole Ten Yards, Tears of the Sun, or Looper?
 
Angel Heart has been nominated once or twice already, these troglodytes won't vote it in.

WHen it gets to me turn the alternatives will be so unpalatable to most they'll have no choice...

Angel Heart
The Colour of Pomegranates
Daisies
Warhole's Empire
 
Martin Riggs is one of my favorite characters ever.

I think one thing about Martin Riggs that makes him attractive as a character, at least to me, is that his lunacy is contrasted by his personal pain.

th
 
I would be tempted to see what you make of Last Year at Marienbad Muster. That thread would probably devolve into an argument about whether Kubrick ripped if off or was influenced by it for The Shining though.
 
I want to go with Semi-Pro but idk how much of a discussion it'll spark.

giphy.gif

I’m with ya, dude.

We have a gentlemens rule not to state which movie we're voting for. So that the voting is completely anonymous and we're not influencing other peoples vote.

Too late! I'm already influenced, pal!

XqB1.gif


Actually, I'm not going to vote for it. Just making a joke.
tenor.gif

As for the Twist Endings list:

* Unbreakable
* The Mist
* Old Boy
* The Usual Suspects
* Dear Zachery

I would have added Pyscho or Planet of the Apes, but I went into them first knowing about the twists, so that spoiled the surprise. Great twists nonetheless.
 
WHen it gets to me turn the alternatives will be so unpalatable to most they'll have no choice...

Angel Heart
The Colour of Pomegranates
Daisies
Warhole's Empire

giphy.gif


I think one thing about Martin Riggs that makes him attractive as a character, at least to me, is that his lunacy is contrasted by his personal pain.

th

Definitely. The way that he barely gets the words "I miss you" out as he's crying/growling in that scene tells you everything that you need to know about the Hell that guy's living in. Contrast that with him watching Bugs Bunny and then signing off with "I'll see you later" and that also tells you everything that you need to know about the guy's wacky personality. That's an economical, informative, and effective scene perfectly conceived, written, and performed.

Fuck, I love those movies. Those are like the Bourne movies or the Dark Knight trilogy for me: I can never just watch one. If I'm watching The Bourne Identity, I'm watching the whole franchise. If I want to watch The Dark Knight, that means I'm watching the whole trilogy.

I can't just "drop by" Riggs and Murtaugh. I have to spend the whole day with them :D

I would be tempted to see what you make of Last Year at Marienbad Muster. That thread would probably devolve into an argument about whether Kubrick ripped if off or was influenced by it for The Shining though.

That's one of those "big" movies that I've actually never seen. I don't even really know what it is. I'm intrigued by the Kubrick connection, though. Is it possible to explain that without spoilers or do I have to watch the movie to get that Kubrick info?
 
Meh? You're not a fan of The Siege, The Whole Nine Yards/The Whole Ten Yards, Tears of the Sun, or Looper?
Looper was good! Willis has just done too many roles and most are meh where as I've enjoyed every Gibson movie I've seen from him last 20 years.
 
Definitely. The way that he barely gets the words "I miss you" out as he's crying/growling in that scene tells you everything that you need to know about the Hell that guy's living in. Contrast that with him watching Bugs Bunny and then signing off with "I'll see you later" and that also tells you everything that you need to know about the guy's wacky personality. That's an economical, informative, and effective scene perfectly conceived, written, and performed.

Fuck, I love those movies. Those are like the Bourne movies or the Dark Knight trilogy for me: I can never just watch one. If I'm watching The Bourne Identity, I'm watching the whole franchise. If I want to watch The Dark Knight, that means I'm watching the whole trilogy.

I can't just "drop by" Riggs and Murtaugh. I have to spend the whole day with them :D

What's really bugging me right now is that my wife and I were watching a movie/tv show/can't remember not too long ago, and I can only recall now that it was trying very hard to drive home the point that this one particular character was grieving/mentally scarred because of a dead wife, but it was coming off too try hard. I remarked to my wife that Mel Gibson as Riggs executed it perfectly in one short scene, while whatever we were watching was really milking it for all it was worth but still coming off as hacky. I guess my point is, I agree that Lethal Weapon movies are awesome. I've said before, and I'll say it again, while the first Die Hard is arguably the best action movie of all time, the Lethal Weapon series as a whole is superior than the Die Hard series as a whole. I like every single Lethal Weapon movie in the franchise. I can't say the same about Die Hard. Not even close.
 
Yea I can't even understand when you have a movie with a twist why they would place that hint on the cover of the DVD. Old or not, that's ridiculous and the person who approved it should get missile kicked.

th
3igx6Ty.gif

Damn, that knee is a potato if I ever saw one.

For you non-wrestling folk:

potato
A strike to the head which makes real contact. - Wikipedia

Hmm, the ending to Planet of the Apes is a potato.
1f914.png

Potatoes are used to make french fries.
Charlton Heston was born in Illinois.
The first McDonald's was founded in Illinois.
Heston was in a movie called Solyent Green.
Solyent Green is an edible wafer.
Heston discovers that Solyent Green is made out of people.
McDonald's serves french fries...

Oh, dear God...
 
intrigued by the Kubrick connection, though. Is it possible to explain that without spoilers or do I have to watch the movie to get that Kubrick info?

On a superficial level the films set in a grand hotel and surrounding gardens with a lot of tracking shots going down hallways, beyond that though I think you could argue a similar kind of meta focus on film/writing, the idea the characters are taking control of narrative of the film.

Honestly it seems like pretty much the ideal film for you being halfway between The Shining and Persona although I spose a bit colder than either with only the odd moment of real drama, again I think would make for great discussion here.
 
This is too big a movie to have qualified as what I considered in my post "under-the-radar," but in general, hell yeah on this one.

giphy.gif


Mickey's best work IMO. And, going back to last week's theme discussion, one of my all-time favorite scenes and the moment where he puts everything together in his head and then starts shrieking is one of my all-time favorite moments.





The members who nominate the picks can vote just like anyone else, but I like the idea of them also being able to abstain. I was actually thinking of doing that for my Bruce Lee week but I didn't know what the deal was with that. Plus, it wouldn't have made a difference on my week anyway. But, in the future, it's good to know. I'd hate to be the deciding vote since, really, I'll want to watch all of the movies I nominate but I'll be the most excited to watch and discuss whatever the club most wants to watch and discuss.

As for this particular poll: Rather than "interesting," I'd say that the standings are terrifying given that the ONE fucking movie that I unequivocally DON'T want to watch is in the running :mad:





Split wasn't bad, but I wasn't all that enamored. Weirdly enough, the first two acts were kind of lame and boring; it wasn't until he got to the last act that things shifted into another gear and I was truly interested in what was going on. I found The Visit way more impressive. When I watched that, I was honestly thinking, "Oh, shit, Shyamalan is finally living up to his promise." You want genuine tension, genuine creepiness, and a fantastic wrap-up that doesn't lose/betray what'd been built leading up to it? The Visit has that shit locked down.



The Village and The Visit are my top two, but I'd probably have Unbreakable in the #3 spot rather than Signs.

I think I may have to check out the visit if its so highly recomended, as I said Shyamalan has, in my eyes, always had potential so it would be great to see it fully realised
 
Honestly if anything I think the focus on the twist downplays how much character Angel Heart has, I'v said it previously but to be it feels like the film Ridley Scott should have been making at that point, Great fun performances ("its anything can happen day") from the leads and superb atmospheric locations.

Its depressing really watching that level of horror cinema and seeing what a ghetto the genre has become these days full of crappy teen jump scare slashers.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Never even heard of it. But if it's got a "Once Upon a Time in" title, then it's got some big shoes to fill. And no, I'm not talking about Robert Rodriguez' shoes.?

Same guy who directed Uzak isn't it? I'd definitely recommend that as a great looking bit of atmospheric cinema, at the very least I think you'd enjoy a scene were the main photographer character is watching Stalker to impress his rural cousin then sticks on porn instead when the cousin goes to bed and hurriedly switches back when he wakes up, nothing at all like my life of course. <45>
 
We Have A Winner!

634281-b.jpg

The poll may read 5-5-5. But by discounting the non-member votes, LHWbelt's vote since he didn't want to vote, and moreorless87's vote (whom joined mid-vote and thus is not eligible to vote), the winner is, in fact, *double checks voting so to make sure every false-vote is properly discountinued*... 2005's Cinderella Man!!! Which member broke the three-way tie, you may ask? Who cast the final vote so to Nominate this film to victory!?

2iyysl.jpg

Members: @europe1 @MusterX @Scott Parker 27 @the muntjac @Cubo de Sangre @sickc0d3r @FrontNakedChoke @AndersonsFoot @Tufts @Coolthulu @Yotsuya @jei @LHWBelt @ArtemV @Bullitt68 @Deus Ex Machina @HenryFlower @Rimbaud82 @moreorless87
 
I would be tempted to see what you make of Last Year at Marienbad Muster. That thread would probably devolve into an argument about whether Kubrick ripped if off or was influenced by it for The Shining though.

220px-Marienbadposter.jpg


During a social meeting at a picturesque and cavernous château with wonderfully ornate rooms, high ceilings and a fine collection of artwork, "X", an enigmatic charming man, approaches "A", an alluring woman, with the intention to convince her that they are not strangers. As a matter of fact, "X" insists that they met the year before at the Czech spa-town of Marienbad, however, the perplexed woman simply has no recollection of their covert romantic encounter. In the end, is "X" telling the truth, furthermore, what really happened last year at Marienbad?

<{Joewithit}>

<TheWire1>
 
Quality flick. Watched it last year. Not something I'll sit through it again though.
 
Back
Top