Movies Rank Em: Pulp Fiction vs Forrest Gump, Shawshank Redemption

Rank Them

  • Pulp, Gump, Shawshank

  • Pulp, Shawshank, Gump

  • Gump, Pulp, Shawshank

  • Gump, Shawshank, Pulp

  • Shawshank, Pulp, Gump

  • Shawshank, Gump, Pulp

Results are only viewable after voting.
GoodBadHBK

GoodBadHBK

Few$More
@Gold
Joined
Apr 6, 2020
Messages
22,557
Reaction score
48,764
For me it's

1. Pulp Fiction
2. Forrest Gump































3. Shawshank Redemption


How about you?
 
definitely have seen Pulp and Shawshank multiple times each over teh years. Have only seen Gump maybe 2 times (but god damn did that shit make me get a little watery eyed and I ain't no bitch, so like whatever) So I remember way more from Pulp and Shaw! imho
 
Last edited:
BEATDOWNS said:
definitely have seen Pulp and Shawshank multiple times each over teh years. Have only seen Gump maybe 2 times (but god damn did that shit make me get a little watery eyed and I ain't no bitch, so like whatever) So I remember way more from Gump and Shaw! imho
Click to expand...

So you voted against Gump because it made you cry.
 
GoodBadHBK said:
So you voted against Gump because it made you cry.
Click to expand...
No but I don't remember much else from it. I made that pretty clear don't get upset because peeps chose different than you. It's ok to be vulnerable sometimes.
 
BEATDOWNS said:
No but I don't remember much else from it. I made that pretty clear don't get upset because peeps chose different than you. It's ok to be vulnerable sometimes.
Click to expand...

I dont care what you vote for but it seems youre upset with Gump because it made you cry.

Cry on i guess.
 
This is gonna boil down to personal preference as both Pulp Fiction and Shawshank are brilliant in their own ways. Id give the edge to Shawshank though. That story masterfully weaves through 20 years as fluidly as you could. Brilliant acring by all and an amazing score, storyline and directing. It was truly a perfect storm for filmmaking. The ending was magic. I could almost say exactly the same for pulp. Im a sucker for movies like shawshank though, so it gets my nod.

Gump was fun and a solid film as well...just not on the same tier as these two.

Fcking crazy year 1994 was. I wish we could get 1 film as good as anything in the top 10 for that year in todays era of shit movies.

We were spoiled and took the arts for granted back then.
 
1. Pulp
2. Shawshank
3. Gump

Pulp Fiction wins this one easily for me, the other two were harder.

I used to like Gump growing up but now I just find the entire movie kinda... dumb. Shawshank is a solid movie, but it boggles my mind that this is #1 on IMDB's top 250.. it wouldn't be in my top 50
 
Shawshank is okay but wildly overrated and Gump is beyond overrated and just boring and dumb. Pulp Fiction is one of the greatest films ever made and maybe the best script ever written. My rankings would be Pulp, Pulp, Pulp.

dylan-chappelle.gif
 
Bullitt68 said:
Shawshank is okay but wildly overrated and Gump is beyond overrated and just boring and dumb. Pulp Fiction is one of the greatest films ever made and maybe the best script ever written. My rankings would be Pulp, Pulp, Pulp.

dylan-chappelle.gif
Click to expand...

iu
 
FG is a gimmick movie and is terribly overrated. Shankshaw is great and arguably the best prison movie ever made.

Pulp Fiction is the GOAT film imo.
 
Gump
Shawshank
Pulp

Not a huge Tarantino fan sans Kill Bill
 
Pulp then Gump.

Pulp is Tarantino's best and a legit classic at this point. Gump isn't anything special but I have heavy nostalgia for it. I hate Stephen King so don't even remember Shawshank tbh.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,280,312
Messages
58,274,908
Members
175,989
Latest member
gorakk

Share this page

Back
Top