Question about sherdogs p4p ranking system?

[blkmike817]

So do these guys even watch the fights. Or are they just throwing darts at a board. You would think having website dedicated to mma that you would have a more credible ranking system or something. Do ya'll just post the rankings just to have something for people to bitch about if so well done. Dos Anjos ranked over MM in your p4p rankings is a little ridiculous don't you think.

 

[johnyboy]

The concept of p4p is pretty ridiculous In itself

 

[smallbets]

Wheres Cruz

 

[blkmike817]

The concept of p4p is pretty ridiculous In itself

ridiculous yes but you think they put a little effort into it especially if they're being paid.

 

[waldywaldy]

Sherdog rankings were never spot on but lately they are a fucking joke.

 

[Jay philips]

The fact that your worried about a P4P list holds no water in itself because for the most part they are based off popularity. If you took 50 people and told them to make up a P4P list they would all be different.

 

[bbandit925]

So do these guys even watch the fights. Or are they just throwing darts at a board. You would think having website dedicated to mma that you would have a more credible ranking system or something. Do ya'll just post the rankings just to have something for people to bitch about if so well done. Dos Anjos ranked over MM in your p4p rankings is a little ridiculous don't you think.

No because MM was unsuccessful at 135 pounds.
P4P greats can move up or down one weight class and still be successful

 

[BigMuffler]

Watching the fights is probably how they ranked RDA over Mighty Mouse since if they went by resume it would clearly be Mighty Mouse ahead.

 

[blkmike817]

No because MM was unsuccessful at 135 pounds.
P4P greats can move up or down one weight class and still be successful

He only lost 2 fights at 135 besides that I think it was a successful run. And I guess title defenses don't count in the p4p ranking. Also not his fault that the talent pool at 125 is shallow.