In regards to Klobuchar. Chuckle. Who da fook is dat?
You're making my point, in part. My claim is that Klobuchar has almost no chance to win the nomination but that she would most likely beat Trump if she could become the nominee.
Trump needs to win the rustbelt again, but that's where Klobuchar is strongest. In 2016, Trump barely won Michigan (margin: 0.23%) despite running against a candidate who is very weak there---voters associate Clinton with NAFTA and TPP, and Wikileaks released an e-mail indicating that Clinton supports some form of "[western] hemispheric open market, with open trade and open borders". It's no wonder that many voters flipped from Obama to Trump in those states.
Klobuchar represents a midwest state (Minnesota) and is very popular there. In head-to-head races, she has proven herself to be a strong candidate as she has consistently outperformed her state's partisan lean. She is also more moderate than many of the Democratic contenders, which would be an advantage in the general election.
As for Buttlick. My brother lives in Indiana. Buttlick is not very popular there & most people before his election had never heard of him. He's a carpet bagger who was parachuted in by the establishment into a very poor area with very low voter turnout. The actual number of people who voted for him was very low. He won because his competition was even lower. As I said before the establishment is fully behind him & are doing their best to make him seem more popular than he really is.
A carpetbagger? He was born in South Bend, Indiana and lived there until he went off to Harvard. He later served as (and continues to serve as) the mayor of South Bend.
What's your source for depressed turnout in Buttigieg's elections? In 2011 he received 74% of the vote. Four years later he was re-elected with 80% of the vote.
Unlike you, I think the RCP polling average is quite accurate. The reason for my belief is past accuracy. It was accurate in 2016, for example. When we consider the current RCP polling average, we see that Buttigieg is already in 4th place despite having <60% name recognition. That's impressive. More subjectively, he is preposterously articulate, handsome and consistently well-dressed and has run a very intelligent campaign so far. He also served in Afghanistan, was a Rhodes Scholar.