No Spoilers Official Red Dead Redemption 2 Discussion

Watching gameplay of this game, It reminds me of why I didnt like the first one very much. Too much open space with nothing really in it. I hope this has more towns than the first one. I want a big industrial town thats pretty big, not just broken up little towns that take 15 minutes each to get to. I say all this being a huge GTA fan. I bought 5 on 3 seperate devices I liked it so much. The reason I cant pass on this game is it will let me know the direction GTA 6 will take as far as gameplay. A little too much RPG elements from what I have seen so far but the shooting looks awesome.
 
Mookie said:
Reviews are pouring in...

IGN: 10/10
Game Informer: 10/10
EGM: 10/10
Game Debate: 10/10
God is a Geek: 10/10
Guardian: 10/10
Telegraph: 10/10
Digital Spy: 10/10

It's currently the highest reviewed game of all time not named Mario or Zelda.
Click to expand...

Even if those were all 9/10 would still be epic. cant wait
 
Probably going to stay off the forums and gamesites for a week til I beat this. Don't want anything spoiled like so many games/shows before.
RockstarChris said:
I have 2 lives now, my life pre RDR2 and my life post RDR2
Click to expand...
This pretty much :D
 
Card charge was processed some hours ago on my preorder. As it's now officially 26.10 here, game on.

Thread title updated accordingly.

cc: @Eazy123
 
We are gonna have to start organizing sherdog posses for when RDROnline drops.

I'm not a huge online gamer but if someone else organized something I'd join.
 
Mookie, do you but be cool, dawg. Accord is always a better podium to speak from than one of antagonism. When you flame thread participants and gratuitously escalate, you're showing disrespect to not only TS, but the Community. You're a welcomed contributor to this discussion; let's keep it that way.

@Mookie
 
Mookie said:
Reviews are pouring in...

IGN: 10/10
Game Informer: 10/10
EGM: 10/10
Game Debate: 10/10
God is a Geek: 10/10
Guardian: 10/10
Telegraph: 10/10
Digital Spy: 10/10

It's currently the highest reviewed game of all time not named Mario or Zelda.
Click to expand...
Verge called it "Breath of the Wild West" lol
 
Valhoven said:
Mookie, do you but be cool, dawg. Accord is always a better podium to speak from than one of antagonism. When you flame thread participants and gratuitously escalate, you're showing disrespect to not only TS, but the Community. You're a welcomed contributor to this discussion; let's keep it that way.

@Mookie
Click to expand...

I agree...Man this is a happy fucking day for gamers!
 
Eazy123 said:
We are gonna have to start organizing sherdog posses for when RDROnline drops.

I'm not a huge online gamer but if someone else organized something I'd join.
Click to expand...
Same. I like to solo most journeys for the agony and achievement of it all but this one has me reconsidering. Reckon I need first hit the open trail and get a feel for what lie ahead. I'm pretty excited to see what firepower and/or explosives are available and slowly adapt my loadout to what I'll call a state of optimal outlawry. ?1?
 
Eazy123 said:
Verge called it "Breath of the Wild West" lol
Click to expand...

Recently re-beat Red Dead Redemption and it was shocking how much Breath of the Wild took from that game! I'm not surprised someone is reverse engineering the comparisons.


Valhoven said:
Mookie, do you but be cool, dawg. Accord is always a better podium to speak from than one of antagonism. When you flame thread participants and gratuitously escalate, you're showing disrespect to not only TS, but the Community. You're a welcomed contributor to this discussion; let's keep it that way.

@Mookie
Click to expand...

I agree with you, yeah? But the problem is they are wrong and stupid and I've been forced to say so.

4Y7eI7A.gif
 
Mookie said:
I'm going over the reviews now...

Fuck Gamespot.

This is the second time now they've handed a Rockstar IP to some dumb bitch to review.

First was that transsexual guy who docked points off GTA5 because it was "sexist" and he / she didn't like how it portrayed teh wahmanz.

Now they give Red Dead Redemption 2 to a fucking 20 year old blonde bitch who's favorite game is Pokemon and favorite past time watching shitty anime (I checked her twitter and bio, trust me it's bad).

She docks points from Red Dead Redemption 2 for...

Wait for it.

Being too realistic.

I remember when games were reviewed by gamers. What a time to be alive.
Click to expand...

Jim Sterling did it too. Not sure why you had to bring in her gender.

I didnt agree with that review I did see it so I am not defending her review.
 
Mookie said:
Reviews are pouring in...

IGN: 10/10
Game Informer: 10/10
EGM: 10/10
Game Debate: 10/10
God is a Geek: 10/10
Guardian: 10/10
Telegraph: 10/10
Digital Spy: 10/10

It's currently the highest reviewed game of all time not named Mario or Zelda.
Click to expand...

Easy Allies gave it 10/10 too.
 
Played for a short bit. I bought it from the Indonesian PSN which had it unlock like 7 hours ago. Was cheaper too.
Looks just amazing. Not too far in yet though.
 
Hyperglide said:
Jim Sterling did it too.
Click to expand...

Not sure why you had to bring in her gender.[/QUOTE]

Jim Sterling has enough estrogen to support the emotional excess of multiple women.

I brought her gender into it because historically women are bad at video games, and even worse at editorials regarding things dealing with politically sensitive subjects... Things like humor and satire!
 
Hyperglide said:
Easy Allies gave it 10/10 too.
Click to expand...
Speaking of, we should have a sherdog game review thread. I know Dragonlord does movie reviews and I'd trust fellow sherdoggers reviews over "official" ones anyway.
 
Mookie said:
Not sure why you had to bring in her gender.
Click to expand...
Jim Sterling has enough estrogen to support the emotional excess of multiple women.

I brought her gender into it because historically women are bad at video games, and even worse at editorials regarding things dealing with politically sensitive subjects... Things like humor and satire!
Click to expand...

What a ridiculous reason. Judge a review on the merits of the review. Not the gender.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,283,068
Messages
58,480,261
Members
176,050
Latest member
giorgevichi

Share this page

Back
Top