Social Not so free to speak: Columbia University ‘refusing to help’ identify people for arrest – White House

[avenue94]

No I'm not genius. Why don't you explain this landmark case to me instead of being a patronizing douche.

It was a simple question, cool your jets. I also don't think it's unreasonable to expect a US citizen to know the 1A'a broad coutures.

It's the Supreme Court case that established the standard for imminent lawless action, and its been reputedly upheld. Speech calling for violence is unprotected only if it is in imminent danger of causing lawless activity.

To give an example of how high that threshold is, the Supreme Court latee held that burning a cross on the lawn of a black family is in of itself protected speech, unless there is intent to intimidate.

 

[avenue94]

Believing every Israeli should die and then running around convincing the youth of such an idea should absolutely be grounds for deportation. If I said the inverse in Hamas territory I would be executed.

Again, why are you asking me or anyone besides the US government for the evidence ? Do you think every time someone gets arrested all the details are made public the next day ?

Except it really isn't because again the first amendment applies to residents. Period. You'd have to show material support for a terrorist group effectively.

And yes...Hamas doesn't like freedom of speech, not sure why you think the US should mirror shit tier governments in the name of reciprocity.


..you are aware arrest records or public information and published quite quickly? There's a reason local news almost always has the details.

 

[tastaylvr]

I'm just some guy on a karate forum, why is the onus on me to provide evidence as to what he said when I am not the one arresting him. Do you really think they arresting him with zero evidence of a crime ?

He is being deported, not prosecuted and incarcerated. Why should the USA tolerate speech that threatens the lives of their allies ?

I'm all for deporting the guy but you sound like a fucking moron. It's like you're overcompensating your MAGAness because you're Canadian.

The maga mind set.

“Meh I don’t now what he did or why he is getting deported but fuck it I’m sure they are right. He looks like what they are saying so it must be true”

Fucking lol

I guess getting a green card ain’t enough anymore.

 

[Hellowhosthat]

Terrorist sympathizers isn’t free speech ..there is also hate laws for antisemitism

Well it is free speech it's just a matter of where you draw the line on it. I've had a few back and forths with Americans.who think they have freedom of speech and it's generally pretty amusing

 

[Hellowhosthat]

Believing every Israeli should die and then running around convincing the youth of such an idea should absolutely be grounds for deportation. If I said the inverse in Hamas territory I would be executed.

Again, why are you asking me or anyone besides the US government for the evidence ? Do you think every time someone gets arrested all the details are made public the next day ?

Do you think people who cheer on the death of Palestinian kids should also be arrested? There's some actor who I keep seeing pop up on social media who keeps doing that

 

[Libero cane v2]

Waiting for all the Maga-people that fawned over Vance’s speech to defend this.

 

[Lycandroid]

The maga mind set.

“Meh I don’t now what he did or why he is getting deported but fuck it I’m sure they are right. He looks like what they are saying so it must be true”

Fucking lol

I guess getting a green card ain’t enough anymore.

I was unaware that all the evidence with regard to every crime except for this one was public knowledge immediately after arrest. Seems rather strange to me.

Do you think people who cheer on the death of Palestinian kids should also be arrested? There's some actor who I keep seeing pop up on social media who keeps doing that

yep

 

[Hellowhosthat]

I was unaware that all the evidence with regard to every crime except for this one was public knowledge immediately after arrest. Seems rather strange to me.

yep

Fair enough, so long as you're consistent.

 

[PhitePhan]

Still looking for a more definitive answer on the legality of this. But don't ask me to feel bad for people who are pro-Hamas.

Does that include Bibi and the other Israeli psychopaths propping Hamas up for the past few decades?