My respective goat lists per division

[TheBeastofHonor]

This is my respective goat lists per division

Overall goat

Jon Jones

Heavyweight goat

Stipe Miocic
Fedor
Cain Velasquez
Francis Ngannou
Daniel Cormier

Light heavyweight goat

Jon Jones
Daniel Cormier
Shogun
Chuck Lidell
Tito Ortiz

Middleweight goat

Israel Adesanya
Anderson Silva
Chris Weidman
Robert Whittaker
Luke Rockhold

Welterweight goat

Kamaru Usman
Gsp
Leon Edwards
Tyron Woodley
Matt Hughes

Lightweight Goat

Islam
Khabib
Olivera
Mcgregor
Alvarez

Featherweight Goat

Aldo
Volkanovski
Holloway
McGregor
Edgar

Bantamweight Goat

Tj Dillashaw
Dominick Cruz
Henry Cejudo
Moreno
Benavediz

Flyweight Goat

Demetrius Johnson
Henry Cejudo

featherweight goat

cyborg

Batmanweight goat

Nunes
 Valentina
Rousey
Meisha Tate
Holm

Flyweight

Valentina
Graso

Straw weight

Joanna
Weillei
Namajunas
Andrade
Esparza

 

[Kowboy On Sherdog]

Izzy over Anderson and Usman over GSP

 

[TheBeastofHonor]

Izzy over Anderson and Usman over GSP

Both were surpassed especially anderson.

 

[Leinster Rugby]

Eeeeeyeahhh... its a "no" from me dawg.

 

[TheBeastofHonor]

Eeeeeyeahhh... its a "no" from me dawg.

Difference in opinion. What's your lists look like?

 

[BROWNPRIDE]

Damn this list is bust and disgusted!

 

[Leinster Rugby]

Difference in opinion. What's your lists look like?

No Jones as overall winner. Fedor not Stipe.

GSP ahead of Usman. Anderson ahead of Izzy.

 

[ROBOCOP]

Neither Izzy or usman couldn't reign as Silva/gsp. Also, I'd have bj Penn in lightweight over Alvarez and Luke rockhold should be replaced by rich Franklin.

 

[TheBeastofHonor]

No Jones as overall winner. Fedor not Stipe.

GSP ahead of Usman. Anderson ahead of Izzy.

Gotta say I disagree here I think both Usman and Adesnya beat better competion than Gsp and Anderson. It was more impressive that Usman Beat them back to back. Gsp had better competion than Anderson but Usman fought(colby) and dominated(Woldley) much stronger wrestlers and was knocking guys out in a row at the tail end of his reign. Anderson for sure had a longer reign than adesnya but adesanya faced greater dangers and more versatile companion.

 

[TheBeastofHonor]

Neither Izzy or usman couldn't reign as Silva/gsp. Also, I'd have bj Penn in lightweight over Alvarez and Luke rockhold should be replaced by rich Franklin.

Lol dude you got it backwards Usman and Izzy had much tougher completion and beat them decisively if anything adesnya and gsp would have been knocked off in izzy and usmans eras.

 

[LindyBrah]

No Jarred Brooks, Ian McCall, John Dodson, or Horiguchi for flyweight?

 

[Substance Abuse]

Troll list for attention.

Must. Not. Feed. The. Troll.

 

[dc007]

Trolls used to at least put in some effort back in the day.

 

[STRAWBOSS]

are we supposed to vote let me know

 

[Dr. Rose]

McGregor should not be in any GOAT lists, let alone LW, where he has a losing record. Zero title defenses in any weight class.

This might be persnickety, but this is also not a GOAT list, but "best of" or "all time great" by division list. Greatest always applies to one, singular. You could do a goat in MMA and goat by division, but it cannot be multiplies when using the term "greatest."

 

[welcometohavoc]

This is my respective goat lists per division

Overall goat

Jon Jones

Heavyweight goat

Stipe Miocic
Fedor
Cain Velasquez
Francis Ngannou
Daniel Cormier

Light heavyweight goat

Jon Jones
Daniel Cormier
Shogun
Chuck Lidell
Tito Ortiz

Middleweight goat

Israel Adesanya
Anderson Silva
Chris Weidman
Robert Whittaker
Luke Rockhold

Welterweight goat

Kamaru Usman
Gsp
Leon Edwards
Tyron Woodley
Matt Hughes

Lightweight Goat

Islam
Khabib
Olivera
Mcgregor
Alvarez

Featherweight Goat

Aldo
Volkanovski
Holloway
McGregor
Edgar

Bantamweight Goat

Tj Dillashaw
Dominick Cruz
Henry Cejudo
Moreno
Benavediz

Flyweight Goat

Demetrius Johnson
Henry Cejudo

featherweight goat

cyborg

Batmanweight goat

Nunes
 Valentina
Rousey
Meisha Tate
Holm

Flyweight

Valentina
Graso

Straw weight

Joanna
Weillei
Namajunas
Andrade
Esparza

Got suspicious when you had Ngannou that high at HW

Suspicions were confirmed when you listed Usman ahead of GSP