MMA goats for each division

[gimmick122]

BJ had some cool wins in weight classes above but he lost his first title fight at lightweight, had a draw in his next lightweight title fight, then won the belt and defended 3 times before losing to Frankie Edgar twice in a row.

Islam has more wins in a row at lightweight than BJ Penn's total wins at lightweight. Islam has more title defenses than BJ.

There's more of an argument for Khabib than BJ.

 

[gosuasus]

Lol stop it

Look, I'd sooner rewatch Mo Smith's or Mario Sperry's fights than sit through Kamaru Usman's padded highlight reel—or whatever overrated flavor of the week you're drooling over. We are not the same, kid. You can now log off and return playing with your barbie dolls.

 

[Simple Southerner]

Look, I'd sooner rewatch Mo Smith's or Mario Sperry's fights than sit through Kamaru Usman's padded highlight reel—or whatever overrated flavor of the week you're drooling over. We are not the same, kid. You can now log off and return playing with your barbie dolls.

Lol yeah ok boomer lol at frank being a ww goat fkn delusional.

 

[Davey Grant]

Now lets do it without the PED users.

 

[Blanqa Blanqua]

Fanboy of who exactly? You the one sweating bj Penn. I like how you dorks love to discount the second half of his ufc career

FUCKIN A

 

[Skarsgard]

125 - Mighty Mouse
135 - Cruz
145 - Aldo/Volk
155 - Arguable for BJ
170 - GSP
185 - Anderson
205 - Arguable for Jones
265 - Arguable for Fedor

 

[Kung Fu Kowboy]

Close enough for being a subjective topic

 

[GOATtalks]

125- DJ
135- Merab
145- Volk/ Ilia
155- Khabib/ Islam
170- GSP
185- Anderson/ Izzy/ Dricus
205- Jones
265- Ngannou

 

[Pequeño Corey]

READ IT AND WEEP FANBOY

These fucking dorks. It’s like, tell me you’re a newb without telling me.

 

[BFoe]

Fedor
Jones
Anderson
GSP
Khabib
Aldo
Cruz
Mighty Mouse

 

[JKS]

BJ Penn fanboys always get a good laugh out of me. Yall are really trying to convince us a run of beating Sean Sherk, Stevenson, Diego Sanchez and Florian is the best we have seen at LW history

I watched BJ’s career from his first UFC fight. I’ve always respected BJ and his talent. But I also know how his limits. He’s got a hardcore fans base that still sees him a goat level fighter.

With all that said, I don’t have BJ as top 5 at LW. Just outside

 

[reddhelium]

Fedor
Jones
Anderson
GSP
Khabib
Aldo
Cruz
Mighty Mouse

 

[Aurelian]

135 is still Cruz.

155 can be either Khabib or Islam

 

[HuskySamoan]

There's no debate in my mind on the bottom 4. The top 4 one could possibly swap tj w/ merab & aldo w/ volk

What say you

HW - Fedor (Slightly debatable)
LHW - Jon Jones (Not debatable)
MW - Anderson Silva (Slightly debatable)
WW - GSP (Not debatable)
LW - Khabib (Debatable)
FW - Jose Aldo (Debatable)
BW - Merab (Very debatable)
FLW - Mighty Mouse (Not debatable)

 

[Simple Southerner]

205 - Arguable for Jones

Stopped reading right here
Why because of "ped`s"

 

[Simple Southerner]

MW - Anderson Silva (Slightly debatable)

Izzy? Lol
Who then imo it's not debatable

 

[BowserJr]

Cruz and Penn

Instead of TJ and Islam

 

[Elegant]

You know someone is either retarded or weren't around to witness TJ's prime when they try to discredit him

We likely never will or at least not for a while witness anything similar to the wizardry that TJ displayed during his peak, the way he set up his combos and chained punches, kicks, and takedowns was literal art

Any true fan of MMA who isn't a virtue signaling weirdo that thinks a fighters personality has anything to do with their fighting ability/legacy knows just how special TJ was

This is MMA in it's absolute most elite/peak form

 

[joy2day]

HW - Fedor (Not debatable)
LHW - Jon Jones (Debatable due to roids)
MW - Anderson Silva (Debatable due to roids)
WW - GSP (Please! The GOAT!)
LW - Motivated Penn (Are you kidding? He's motivated!)
FW - WEC Aldo (Marginally debatable)
BW - Cruz (Debatable)
FLW - Mighty Mouse (Not debatable)

 

[Skarsgard]

Stopped reading right here
Why because of "ped`s"

Feels a little silly. You had one left.
Less the PEDs and moreso the blatant cheating in each fight and a few gift decisions. If your answer to having weak boxing is to just eye gouge your opponent, then it puts asterisks.
His heavyweight exhibitions aren't being considered for obvious reasons.