- Joined
- Jun 13, 2005
- Messages
- 66,111
- Reaction score
- 37,419
I regard global warming as the greatest threat facing humanity, and my top political preoccupation. The episode deliberately conflates that with pulp progressive gobbledygook about the wealth gap in the most obnoxious, hamfisted tone imaginable. It's a sermon. Someone needs to tell Hollywood to save that shit for Sunday school.I agree completely on 3.1 being preachy. While I suspect I agree with the politics behind the preaching more than you do I can't stand attempts at 'satire' which lack all subtly. I also didn't like how 2022 it was in its references, for me, Sci-fi should look at a bigger picture of the human experience than some cheap rednecks are bad and lol Elon Musk jokes. I quite liked the animation of it though.
Who cares about "innovative"? A story doesn't have to be innovative to be great. It was High Noon on the high seas. It was the story of a stoic hero of staunch moral conviction employing cleverness to overcome seemingly impossible adversity when out-muscled, out-numbered, and generally beset from all sides. There is no tale more timeless than this.3.2 actually highlights for me while my enjoyment of the series is decreasing over time. It was a good episode but it felt a little formulaic. I think I would have loved it if it was part of S1 but the very realistic animation style combined with a grim story of gory death and the depths of human character. I suppose it didn't feel very innovative to me.
That episode isn't preaching, and I think that's why many are looking past it.I agree that 3.6 probably deserves higher than I gave it in my initial ranking. I wanted more time seeing the swarm than exploring the human love interest. It did showcase how to have a potentially 'preachy' message that humans are greedy but doing it as much more of a subtle undertone.
Greed isn't suggested to be man's downfall. On the contrary, the doctor refuses the proposal to be absorbed into the Swarm to preserve humanity as a caste, and earlier, as the doctor cogently argues to his partner, leveraging the industriousness of the Swarm would be no more evil than running an apiary. No, the episode takes a much wider view of the unflinching, amoral character of mother nature, and what drives evolutionary success. It is a meditation on the unforeseen, but unavoidable dangers of manipulating nature to enhance our species' quality of life.
Science isn't without risk.