To quote William Wong:
"The deltoids stop working at 90 degrees of abduction. That's about the starting position for this exercise! So what are you really working here? Your upper back some, and your triceps a lot. Your deltoids act as fixators; muscles that support the joint and allow movement to happen. But they do not act as prime movers or even agonists (in other words the deltoids don't do much here at all). What this exercise will do is to wreck the rear of your rotator cuff"
Sauce on 90 degress stop working thing.
What's wrong with improving upper back and tricep strength? I don't know shit, but this seems like a great way to improve overhead stability in the snatch.
Not sure I really believe the wrecking your rotator cuff part.
Its crap.
Back when weightlifters did them all the time, no one had problems. I have done them for more than 30 years. SGPBTN were often used to build stability in the shoulders and upper back to assist in fixing the bar overhead in the snatch.
Would you recommend Klokov's to people who are training to get stronger, but who aren't Olympic Lifters?
Would you recommend Klokov's to people who are training to get stronger, but who aren't Olympic Lifters?
Why not just press?
Why not just press?
I did these when I was
younger almost religously, didn't have any problems. Then I stopped when
I read an article that said they were bad...
To quote William Wong:
"The deltoids stop working at 90 degrees of abduction. That's about the starting position for this exercise! So what are you really working here? Your upper back some, and your triceps a lot. Your deltoids act as fixators; muscles that support the joint and allow movement to happen. But they do not act as prime movers or even agonists (in other words the deltoids don't do much here at all). What this exercise will do is to wreck the rear of your rotator cuff"
I do; I meant as an assistance exercise to regular Pressing.
Not really. Unless you have a wobbly bar path on the press, then you might get a little more stability, I suppose. Otherwise things like push press and close grip bench press are better options. Really, most people who do not snatch really do not need this exercise.
I do them, but it is to maintain stability in the snatch/power snatch. Noticed when I quit doing them for extended periods of time I was not quite as solid at the top. But that is a personal thing, given my extra-length arms. I know plenty of guys who put up bigger numbers than me and they never do this exercise.
I hate those articles.