Warning: Lots of pondering in this one:
It'd be interesting to compare Americrican Football players to Pro fighters.
-Helmets vs 4 oz gloves.
-Effects of cutting weight for smaller fighters vs players.
-Kickers and QBs who aren't supposed to get regularly clobbered
-(As some one mentioned earlier) Getting blind sided in football vs hardly ever in MMA
- 5 fights max (all of which might not be against the best fighters) in a years vs 17-20 games (right?) per season including the playoffs which should have the best players (not sure if that has an effect.
-etc...
Also, to have the same/similar sort of rabid fan base as athletes who play team sports, it seems like fighters need to be (and train in) a particular place to have the same rabid fanbase that a local sports team does.
In modern MMA
(and I'm not contending that all of these have massive local followings,) I think of guys like Oliveira, Conor, Paddy, Paul Craig, Edwards, Weidman before he left LI, Sanchez, Holly Holm, Matt Serra, etc... who live/train locally.
Baseball... Would be great if your kids could ever make it to the big leagues(which will never happen, realistically).
The key might be to move to the Dominican Republic (don't @ me over security, etc...) since those kids end up end up making it to the majors at a significantly higher rate than our kids do here in the states.
To be fair if Chandler gets 25 sacks which is about where he should be in 3 years he'd be top ten all time. Its not like he's just been an average player. He has been a very good DE for a long time. At his age though that does seem like a terrible contract for the team.
To your point though, yes UFC fighters are underpaid.
Team sports are tougher re: determining ATG status for individual players.
I'm sure that there are American Football fanatics who may have something to say to the contrary; but if Barry Sanders had played with even a half decent offensive line, I doubt that anyone would've cared
(hyperbole of course) about any other running back at the time or since.
He has at times led the NFL in sacks, tackles for loss, forced fumbles, and fumbles recovered.
There you go!
With team sports, each player brings their own specific dynamic to the overall team.
A guy like GSP will literally train MT & BJJ in NYC, MMA in Montreal, boxing with Freddie Roach (LA?,) etc...
He doesn't need to fulfill a certain role within a "team."
And theoretically, anyone with sufficient financial backing would be able to do the same thing.