- Joined
- Jan 20, 2013
- Messages
- 32,667
- Reaction score
- 63,752
Agreed with the rest but the Dustin title fight was legitimately good and a nice reward for fighting down against a surging contender (who admittedly has gotten destroyed since then). But Dustin made it to the 5th round and put a huge gash on Islam, that's better than Oliveira did
I have been a Dustin Poirier fan since the Fightville documentary, and I was a big WEC fan.
But the fact remins that he was most definitely NOT the most deserving title contender. He beat BSD who was ranked #11 or #12.
Charles at that point had victories over most of the top 5 via stoppage at that point. Sub Gaethje, Sub Dustin, TKO Chandler, UD Beniel
If champs fought 2-3x per year like Matt Hughes, then you could get away with a throw away title fight every once in a while, but these days once every 9 months is about how often we can see a champ, so if you do a "just for fun" title defense you win up with only 1 legitimate title defense in 18-27 months. That is the recipe for rank squatting because if the shot only comes up once every year and a half then it doesn't make sense to risk your rank vs a lower ranked guy,
which gets us where we are right now with 4 guys claiming they are next and refusing to fight anyone but the champ and meanwhile the entire top 5 is sitting with no fight booked.