• Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.

Give me one reason why UFC shouldn't adopt ONEFC method

Apollo33

Brown Belt
@Brown
Joined
May 5, 2011
Messages
3,997
Reaction score
1,620
I am so tired of the distraction and drama with this archaic in effective way of weigh in fighters.

How many fights are we going to be robbed of because of this before we stop to think how completely stupid illogical this whole water cutting thing is.

The entire point of weight classes is to make sure fighters fight at the same weight on fight night, so fighters do not gain an advantage due to being heavier. Does the current weigh in achieve this is any way shape or form???

as most of you know this is what ONE has been doing

“We use an instrument to test the specific gravity of their urine, which tests how much solutes are in their urine,” he continued. “Obviously, the more [solutes] you have, the more dehydrated you are.”

Fighters are tested multiple times for both weight and hydration during fight week. Failure to achieve adequate levels of hydration — or weight — will also result in additional, event-day testing.

“We will not allow our athletes to compete dehydrated,” Franklin said. “But if they happen to be overweight, if they’re hydrated but maybe a half a pound over or something like that, we can negotiate a catchweight. We have parameters for that. They have to be at least 105 percent of their opponent’s weight.”



Obviously there's going to be a lot of changes, weight classes, logistics, contracts etc. I just cannot see this being a worse thing than we have now once all the kinks are figured out.

We get fully healthy hydrated fighters going into the cage AT THE SAME WEIGHT. No more missed fights, no more excuses. Fighters have entire training camp to make sure their NATURAL weight is compliant with the OFFICIAL weight.

Give me reasons why this is a bad idea.
 
1. We cant pretend guys like this are 170

20160130090304_5D3_3894.JPG
 
It would be just another envelope fighters would try to push.
 
It would be just another envelope fighters would try to push.

True, but I don't see how fighters can cheat this. You have to weigh in and pass a hydration test. How can they cheat the hydration piss test.
 
Conflict of interest probably. There is money to be saved or made somehow is my best guess. Money rules everything after all.
 
Conflict of interest probably. There is money to be saved or made somehow is my best guess. Money rules everything after all.

I can see it being more complicated because you need more staff doing piss test and multiple weigh in's. However how much money has the UFC lost in the past few years due to Main events getting cancelled because fighters almost die from cutting weight.

Maybe it's an issue with the athletic commissions..
 
because one(fc) doesn't even use their own method.

I didn't know that? why is that. I heard it's because of corruption or something.

However, there's no reason why UFC can't adopt it and have the commission over see it
 
I didn't know that? why is that. I heard it's because of corruption or something.

However, there's no reason why UFC can't adopt it and have the commission over see it

i mean, i don't know all the reasons or whatever, but yeah - they've definitely shown a lot of favoritism regarding it and if they even attempt to enforce it, it's highly selective at best.
 
The crazy thing is that fighters usually perform better when they dont have to cut weight and yet everyone keep doing it.
 
Too stubborn to adopt something another org created. The ego of the ufc will never admit another promotion got it better. And therefore will never adopt new things.

It really is a pride issue.
 
I can see it being more complicated because you need more staff doing piss test and multiple weigh in's. However how much money has the UFC lost in the past few years due to Main events getting cancelled because fighters almost die from cutting weight.

Maybe it's an issue with the athletic commissions..
The athletic commissions aren't involved in this. ONE FC pays for it and its quite simple. Fighters get their walking weight verified by ONE FC's HMO network year round. The urine test is only for fight week and its just a few times and its very cheap.

There are rumors that ONE FC bends the rules for certain fighters they favor who are overweight but that doesn't mean that the system is inherently bad. I think they can't get around the idea that some small org in a no name country managed to come up with something better.
 
Here’s a reason: there’s no actual evidence that the system actually works. ONE’s process is in the dark and very hush hush.

Ben Askren saying it works means nothing, because he’s now an executive for them, ie, a paid shill.

The athletic commissions aren't involved in this. ONE FC pays for it and its quite simple. Fighters get their walking weight verified by ONE FC's HMO network year round. The urine test is only for fight week and its just a few times and its very cheap.

There are rumors that ONE FC bends the rules for certain fighters they favor who are overweight but that doesn't mean that the system is inherently bad. I think they can't get around the idea that some small org in a no name country managed to come up with something better.

There’s no commission involved in ONE because there is no commission where they operate. No oversight at all.
 
Here’s a reason: there’s no actual evidence that the system actually works. ONE’s process is in the dark and very hush hush.

Ben Askren saying it works means nothing, because he’s now an executive for them, ie, a paid shill.



There’s no commission involved in ONE because there is no commission where they operate. No oversight at all.

But we do have athletic commissions here, if anything we need them to adopt something similar so there's no bs. I mean they oversee weigh ins now, they even have doctors and officials monitoring fighter's health. They can be the third party that does the tests so it's not in the dark like ONE.

I have yet to see the athletic commission favoring the UFC at weigh-ins, if anything they have called off more fights due to fighter's health
 
you'd have the same problem you do with any rule change. first getting the commissions to agree to it, and then having them all implement it. You'd have a patchwork of states that have the new rules with new weigh ins, some with new rules and old weigh ins, etc. So you'd have even more situations like one of the other posts here was arguing for Yoel, where a fighter might miss weight in a certain commission's territory but be within the limit for a different commission.
 
Just have same day weigh-ins. If some fatass like Hendricks wants to try to cut massive amounts of weight, he’ll be the one to pay.
<{JustBleed}>
 
Back
Top