That was one of my all time favorites. I know that Gary might not have been the most elite-level opponent, but that was the fight that blew me away with the way Fedor mixed his striking with his takedowns and grappling. Fighters still don't blend it like that, even those who come from similar backgrounds as Fedor.
I find his takedown strategy really interesting from the double underhook body lock, and I never noticed his preference for this before. He likes that position, but unlike most people, he doesn't seem to like to finish with a trip when he has double underhooks and locks the hands. He does a lift and rotation, then brings his weight down. It's really not a like a suplex or suplex attempt, seems to be a lot more tiring than an outside trip (or ko-soto gari if you prefer). Any thoughts on this?
Is Fedor being the GOAT HW really even arguable?
Assuming you're talking about the throw he uses that I think you mean (for some reason the gifs didn't show up in my browser at the start of the thread), its modification for no-gi on the common competition sasae tsurikomi ashi ... and its a fairly common throw in high level judo competition. The text book sasae you see in gradings (or Nage-no-kata) which is done at arms length isn't the competition version; the competition version has body contact, and is more or less what Fedor does, except its done with a gi grip instead of double underhooks.
And I was told by a judo coach who was also on the Russian national team at the same time, that that sasae was one of Fedor's favorite throws when competing in judo, so its not surprising he modified it for MMA.
For reference for noobs (like me) who don't know that technique. As I see it, the idea behind the TD's are the same (first get the opponent off-balance by focusing on their upper-body [Fedor uses an underhook, Judo guys use the pulling motion on the gi] and then capitalize by taking them down focusing on their lower-body [Fedor uses his arm like a wrestling TD to grab behind the knee, while Judo guys use their foot to trip]) but the actual execution is considerably different, with Fedor making it more of a throw than a trip.
It looked a lot more like wrestling than Judo. Not being sarcastic.
As I said, the gif of Fedor's throw doesn't show up in my browser, but I assume this is the one people are talking about (and that I've seen Fedor do in MMA).
Fedor is one of the most talented fighters ever, despite in my opinion never even reaching his true potential.
It looked a lot more like wrestling than Judo. Not being sarcastic.
The techniques in judo and wrestling are the same, other than the variations between gi and no-gi. Flying mare/seoi nage, hip toss/o goshi, body lock/sasae tsurikomi ashi, mule kick/uchi mata ... for that matter, kimura/ude garami/key lock.
If you learn a technique in wrestling, then its a wrestling technique for you. Someone else learns the same technique in judo, its a judo technique for them. In Fedor's case, he was on the Russian national judo team (3rd best team in the world, much better qualifications than say Karo had, though not as good as Yoshida), and he learned his throws in judo, so for him they're judo. Randy Couture does exactly the same throws, and they're wrestling takedowns, because that's where he learned them.
The human body only moves in so many ways, and there aren't any new techniques, just modifications. Every technique in judo, wrestling, BJJ, sambo, you name it, has been around for thousands of years. There've been modifications, and they're set up differently, and taught more systematically at some times than others, but they don't belong to judo or wrestling or BJJ etc.
No one in MMA has really put together striking and takedown like Fedor did. There's nobody that moves like him.
Khabib and Rustam are similar. Dat combat Sambo.