It's between the first two, the rest cannot compete. I just recently got the RE4 2005 version on Steam because it's in 60fps and it looks great but overall it's not a Resident Evil game. It's so repetitive and linear, it lacks any real substance (virtually no atmosphere and puzzles, which is what the original REs were known for). Fun, but I feel the best part of it is the Mercenaries bonus game and Separate Ways is a nice addition too, especially because it's quite long for a side game.