- Joined
- Jun 3, 2009
- Messages
- 86,730
- Reaction score
- 26,192
Update: August 4, 2015
Dragonlord's Review of FANTASTIC FOUR (2015)
Bottom Line: With a dark, grounded sci-fi approach, Josh Trank's Fantastic Four takes a long time to set up but breaks apart during the second half with a disjointed direction, lack of character interactions and overall poor script.
Fox's Fantastic Four reboot underwent a lot of negative press, from the Johnny Storm casting to the the studio being displeased at how the film turned out to director Josh Trank's rumored erratic behavior during production. But there was a glimmer of hope when the amazing first trailer was released which conveyed the film as a dark sci-fi adventure. Unfortunately all the reported production problems turned out to be true.
The film takes a long time setting up how the team got their powers. Didn't really mind the long origin story as the narrative was quite compelling. Having followed the production from the start, my mindset had already adjusted to the fact that this was going to take a lot of liberties from the source material. Felt like a dark, grounded science fiction drama with a dash of David Cronenberg-esque body horror vibe rather than the typical superhero movie with the first half of the film and the character development being decently entertaining. Ironically, the film goes downhill when our heroes finally get their powers.
The major problems start to pile up when the narration time-jumps to one year in the second half of the film. There's a sense of disjointedness in the plot direction and character development after the fast-forward. Much of the film is narrated through the eyes of Reed Richards. So when Reed disappears in a pointless interlude, the film also loses its identity. The four main characters barely have any interaction with one another and the family dynamic and team chemistry were non-existent. The rushed pace, terrible dialogue and a landfill of exposition didn't help either. Instead of building up the threat, Doctor Doom's re-emergence near the end felt tacked on. The sad part is that the film's actual running time is 100 minutes but could easily added 20-30 minutes to boost character development and fix the pacing problems.
It's too bad the script doesn't match the young, talented cast assembled. Among the four, Miles Teller as Reed Richards shines the most as the dorky genius. Her face is normally a bit off-putting for me but Kate Mara was pretty in here and did a solid job as Sue Storm. The terrific Jamie Bell as Ben Grimm was shortchanged as he was notably absent from the first half of the movie (and going back to my complaint of very few character interactions). Despite all the hoopla and controversy over his casting, Michael B. Jordan as Johnny Storm was nothing special. Except for Reed, the other three members lacked any significant character development.
The action at the finale was pretty shoddy. Some of the special effects look bad like the Human Torch's flame form. Doctor Doom looks so terrible it makes you yearn for the bad Julian McMahon version. One cool and surprisingly brutal aspect of Doom's power is to easily blow up people's heads Scanners-style leaving a lot of blood splatter as a result. Inexplicably, Doom doesn't use these techniques to dispatch the heroes when they battle. Another minus is that they don't properly explain what Doom's powers are. The Thing looks and sounds good but still wish he would wear pants/underwear even if he doesn't have any genitalia anymore.
Overall, the first half of the movie was fairly good but everything got screwed up after the one-year time-jump. The film is like a 4-part mini-series, but the 2nd episode was never shown and the 3rd and 4th episodes are crammed into one. You deduct 3+ stars to my rating if you are one of those persons who can't accept drastic changes from the source material or hate this film's casting. If you want an excellent Fantastic Four movie, just watch The Incredibles again.
RATING: 4.5/10
Table of Contents:
Post 1: Dragonlord's Review
Post 2: Dragonlord's 14 Ways to Fix Fantastic Four Fiasco
Post 3-13: Details on the Troubled Production
Post 20: Dragonlord's F4 Fantasy Casting
Link to previous thread: http://forums.sherdog.com/forums/f48/fantastic-four-reboot-first-trailer-released-2457401/
Dragonlord's Review of FANTASTIC FOUR (2015)
Bottom Line: With a dark, grounded sci-fi approach, Josh Trank's Fantastic Four takes a long time to set up but breaks apart during the second half with a disjointed direction, lack of character interactions and overall poor script.
Fox's Fantastic Four reboot underwent a lot of negative press, from the Johnny Storm casting to the the studio being displeased at how the film turned out to director Josh Trank's rumored erratic behavior during production. But there was a glimmer of hope when the amazing first trailer was released which conveyed the film as a dark sci-fi adventure. Unfortunately all the reported production problems turned out to be true.
The film takes a long time setting up how the team got their powers. Didn't really mind the long origin story as the narrative was quite compelling. Having followed the production from the start, my mindset had already adjusted to the fact that this was going to take a lot of liberties from the source material. Felt like a dark, grounded science fiction drama with a dash of David Cronenberg-esque body horror vibe rather than the typical superhero movie with the first half of the film and the character development being decently entertaining. Ironically, the film goes downhill when our heroes finally get their powers.
The major problems start to pile up when the narration time-jumps to one year in the second half of the film. There's a sense of disjointedness in the plot direction and character development after the fast-forward. Much of the film is narrated through the eyes of Reed Richards. So when Reed disappears in a pointless interlude, the film also loses its identity. The four main characters barely have any interaction with one another and the family dynamic and team chemistry were non-existent. The rushed pace, terrible dialogue and a landfill of exposition didn't help either. Instead of building up the threat, Doctor Doom's re-emergence near the end felt tacked on. The sad part is that the film's actual running time is 100 minutes but could easily added 20-30 minutes to boost character development and fix the pacing problems.
It's too bad the script doesn't match the young, talented cast assembled. Among the four, Miles Teller as Reed Richards shines the most as the dorky genius. Her face is normally a bit off-putting for me but Kate Mara was pretty in here and did a solid job as Sue Storm. The terrific Jamie Bell as Ben Grimm was shortchanged as he was notably absent from the first half of the movie (and going back to my complaint of very few character interactions). Despite all the hoopla and controversy over his casting, Michael B. Jordan as Johnny Storm was nothing special. Except for Reed, the other three members lacked any significant character development.
The action at the finale was pretty shoddy. Some of the special effects look bad like the Human Torch's flame form. Doctor Doom looks so terrible it makes you yearn for the bad Julian McMahon version. One cool and surprisingly brutal aspect of Doom's power is to easily blow up people's heads Scanners-style leaving a lot of blood splatter as a result. Inexplicably, Doom doesn't use these techniques to dispatch the heroes when they battle. Another minus is that they don't properly explain what Doom's powers are. The Thing looks and sounds good but still wish he would wear pants/underwear even if he doesn't have any genitalia anymore.
Overall, the first half of the movie was fairly good but everything got screwed up after the one-year time-jump. The film is like a 4-part mini-series, but the 2nd episode was never shown and the 3rd and 4th episodes are crammed into one. You deduct 3+ stars to my rating if you are one of those persons who can't accept drastic changes from the source material or hate this film's casting. If you want an excellent Fantastic Four movie, just watch The Incredibles again.
RATING: 4.5/10
Table of Contents:
Post 1: Dragonlord's Review
Post 2: Dragonlord's 14 Ways to Fix Fantastic Four Fiasco
Post 3-13: Details on the Troubled Production
Post 20: Dragonlord's F4 Fantasy Casting
Link to previous thread: http://forums.sherdog.com/forums/f48/fantastic-four-reboot-first-trailer-released-2457401/
Last edited: