I think 20% is a bit harsh for .25 pounds. Maybe the fine should be more proportionate to the weight exceeded, something like:
< 0.49lb = 10%
< 0.99lb = 12.5%
< 1.99lb = 15%
> 2lb = 20%
edit: Having such a system would at least encourage fighters to try their best to weigh in as close to their opponents' weight as they can even when they know they won't make weight. There have been fighters coming in 5-10 pounds overweight and we all know that it's a very significant advantage.
< 0.49lb = 10%
< 0.99lb = 12.5%
< 1.99lb = 15%
> 2lb = 20%
edit: Having such a system would at least encourage fighters to try their best to weigh in as close to their opponents' weight as they can even when they know they won't make weight. There have been fighters coming in 5-10 pounds overweight and we all know that it's a very significant advantage.
Last edited: