- Joined
- Sep 2, 2004
- Messages
- 12,186
- Reaction score
- 10,138
It’s not just Fedor though. GSP had his fight with Hendricks and walked away from the sport at age 32.
Jose Aldo is only 35, yet he’s 5-5 in his last 10–and that’s only possible by making adjustments to his game and dropping weight classes to 135, which would’ve been unthinkable 10 years ago. Why? Because he’s been fighting since he was 18 and has a ton of mileage. In his first decade of fighting he was 25-1. In his second decade, he’s 5-6.
BJ Penn? Debuted at age 23. He went 16-7-2 (4 of those 7 losses are to GSP and Frankie) in his first decade, and went 0-7 in his second decade. Fell off a cliff at age 33.
See the pattern?
I agree that Moose is an exception, but exceptions are just that: they’re exceptions, not the rule. It does seem clear that he’s declining now, and his recent opposition is kind of questionable (2 declining WWs in Rory and Lima, and I question exactly how good Carvalho or Salter are). We’ll have to keep an eye on Moose. I’m a big fan though, so hopefully he can keep fighting at a decently high level for awhile. But I doubt it.
You also have to consider that the longer you fight, the more tape there is to study, and the better the competition gets. Those guys you listed are also exceptions, by the way, not the rule, and their losses aren't due to loss of muscle strength/density, speed, and reflexes, which is what being "old" or "out of prime" entails. Their competition caught up to them. The physical declines start around 36-37, and will obviously be worse in those plagued with injuries.