I'm not interested in hypotheticals where one technique may or may not be more or less efficient for different fighters against different opponents. I'm talking about mcgregor. He gets less done when he's spamming jumping and spinning kicks, more done when he's pressuring with his boxing.
Yeah I agree he does get more done when he's pressuring with his boxing but I feel part of the reason he does well in that regard is precisely because of the random flashy kick - his opponents for the most part are hesitant to attack him when he's throwing flashy - I think that's the purpose of it all, to make them hesitant and get them in that mindset then following up with boxing pressure to force the mistake and the mistake comes when you've been put in that mindset.
Might not agree with what he's doing but I can understand why he might be opting for it.
That said I don't think he'll be able to do that against the top dogs of the division like Frankie Edgar, Aldo or Swanson. As he is at the moment, I don't see him beating either Edgar or Aldo, it's a toss up between Swanson though.
I agree with your points about unpredictability, but I like when he does that to only a small degree. The buchinger fight is a good example, as is the brandao fight. Those kicks are most efficient when he throws one or two a round, and he's most effective when that's what he's doing but mostly using his boxing. Basic is better than unpredictable. The best fighters generally use a relatively small number of basic techniques and their skill is in the application, which conor has nearly mastered for his boxing but isn't even close to with his flashy kicks.
I'm pretty much the same in that regard as well. Unpredictability can be a good thing when done in small doses but it's also a double edged sword, he could easily leave himself exposed or perhaps have an unpredicted outcome and be made to pay for it.
I agree with you as well - definitely about basic techniques because that's when you can really specialise in them & apply them in ways others can't. But that said you can't discount the value of having a high risk/high reward technique or having something else to fall back on to, in case things don't go your way.
If we take the example of Machida - his shotokan approach while incredibly effective and yet very basic fundamentals is also his weakness because that's all he knows (prior to his recent change). He is soo good of the back foot and countering, that when he had to pressure or go on the front foot he couldn't do it as well.....which resulted in him having to try and adapt & change himself because he realised that you need something to fall back on to. Connor has those flashy kicks in his repertoire, yes his technique might not be great or it might not be better than his hands but should his hands not save him, at least he has that facet to rely on or even use to make sure his hands land more by being unpredictable and making his opponent feel hesitant.
If you watched last night's fight Poirier avoided him nearly every time he did anything flashy - I feel as though Connor uses it to get into their head along with the trash talk to try to establish mental dominance.
But that said instead of learning flashy kicks he'd be better equipped to learn kicks which fit in neatly with his pressuring.