• We are currently experiencing technical difficulties. We sincerely apologize for the inconvenience.

Cat Stevens and Jim Croce.

fishbisquit

Yellow Belt
@Yellow
Joined
Sep 26, 2024
Messages
229
Reaction score
269
What do you think of these guys if you even know who they are. They banged out whole albums that were great. Folky type music, but shit a guy that liked Metallica could like. Same with Lightfoot and Stan Rogers. They had power in the music and lyrics.
 
What do you think of these guys if you even know who they are. They banged out whole albums that were great. Folky type music, but shit a guy that liked Metallica could like. Same with Lightfoot and Stan Rogers. They had power in the music and lyrics.
They're on my rotation Jim died way too soon.
 
both had some classic, terrific songs but I personally don't know much about them beyond their hits, love those hits though. Croce died young so he'll always get that attention for that but the songs were really great, varied and had depth. You wouldn't expect the guy who wrote Leroy Brown to write Time in a Bottle. The era they were in was conducive to singer songwriters, that was all the rage for the first half of the 70's. John Denver, Joni Mitchell, Carly Simon on and on, and they even tried to squeeze Bruce Springsteen into that vein and he seemed to feed into it somewhat but eventually introduced the full band and the entire epic jersey scenery into his music. Some people, very few, still think Bruce's sparse, acoustic work is his most powerful but I don't think any of his albums done in that fashion sold all that well. Nebraska and Tom Joad have their fans though.
 
This is funny, I was just talking about work about Jim Croce. He died so young, I think when he was like 32, but he had so many great songs and the guy looked 55. It was insane, finding out how young he was when he died. Absolutely one of my favorites.
 
This is funny, I was just talking about work about Jim Croce. He died so young, I think when he was like 32, but he had so many great songs and the guy looked 55. It was insane, finding out how young he was when he died. Absolutely one of my favorites.
yup, i can't think about him without thinking how much older he looked than he was.
 
Croce was a great storyteller, listen to him quite often
 
Jim Croce was great. I obviously grew up with Leroy Brown on the radio as a kid, and yeah he was a good story teller.

I got reintroduced to him by a flatmate on one drunken evening of listening to music 25 years ago. I still listen to him occasionally.

Cat Stevens I don't care about.
 
What do you think of these guys if you even know who they are. They banged out whole albums that were great. Folky type music, but shit a guy that liked Metallica could like. Same with Lightfoot and Stan Rogers. They had power in the music and lyrics.
Fun fact, they both converted religion at some point during their careers.

Cat converted to Islam and Jim converted to Judaism
 
Cat Stevens was one of the greatest songwriters ever before he went religious.

Croce had a few solid tunes, too, though not as familiar with him.
 
I had 4 or 5 Cat Stevens albums as a kid. Beautiful music, unique lyrics that were insightful and took you on a journey. Jim Croce I heard on the radio sometimes, but I never liked him enough to start buying albums, so I can't really comment on his music with authority. I just know maybe a half dozen of his songs.

Just after Cat Stevens converted to Islam, he came to my city to speak about his new religion. It was free to see him, and the place was packed. We all wanted to hear him sing. That's why we were there. He wasn't there to sing Cat Stevens songs, but we were drawn anyway. At some point he started singing a Muslim prayer, and we were ecstatic. The place was going to erupt after he finished, but just after he finished he loudly told us not to applaud for some religious reasons, can't remember what they were. So we all kept it in. But it was thrilling to hear that voice again, even if it was to a Muslim prayer.
 
I love all of Jim Croce's big hits.

I don't think I know any cat Stevens songs other than cats in the cradle, but that's a good song.
 
I love all of Jim Croce's big hits.

I don't think I know any cat Stevens songs other than cats in the cradle, but that's a good song.
This is right in with the topic, and as much as that sounds like cat Stephens, it is harry chappin. Really close in sound and lyrics to father and son.
 
What happened? Did he stop making music or did his music just suck afterwards?
He converted. He went full muslim. There are some real award vids of him more recently as an 80 year old hoping to get his musical career back.
 
He converted. He went full muslim. There are some real award vids of him more recently as an 80 year old hoping to get his musical career back.
Morning has broken is still the goat Christian hymn. A tragedy he lost his way.
 
Morning has broken is still the goat Christian hymn. A tragedy he lost his way.
that and peace train are great songs. I never thought they were hymnals but I don't know much about the guy. I know he turned semi fanatic muslim.
 
This is right in with the topic, and as much as that sounds like cat Stephens, it is harry chappin. Really close in sound and lyrics to father and son.
harry chapin is very similar in style and sensibility. Haven't gotten to listen to much of his music either.
 
Back
Top