Captain America vs. Black Panther: Who would win?

[Sakuraba is #1]

Captain America List of Powers and Abilities:

-Superhuman Strength and Speed
-Senses, Agility, and Reflexes enhanced by -Super Soldier serum
-Nearly Indestructible Vibranium Shield
-Master of all forms of hand-to-hand combat
-Superior Strategic Mind


Black Panther List of Powers and Abilities:

-Superhuman Strength and Speed
-Senses, Agility, and Reflexes enhanced by the heart-shaped herb
-Vibranium-laced suit that absorbs, stores, and redirects kinetic energy
-Vibranium Claws
-Brilliant Tactical Mind

Their physical abilities are nearly equal. Cap is stronger but Black Panther is more agile. The outcome of their battle comes down to their equipment. Black Panther’s advanced technology gives him the winning edge.

 

[Other]

Do we really want to pit these two against one another? In today's social and political climate?

 

[Aegon Spengler]

Cap is friends with Thor and Chadwick is dead so you do the math

 

[ChosenOne]

Isn't Cap 'Peak Human', in all areas, whereas BP is slightly above Peak Human?

@Anung Un Rama

 

[Rob Battisti]

Isn't Cap 'Peak Human', in all areas, whereas BP is slightly above Peak Human?

@Anung Un Rama

Yes but BP has some good suit tech but then again Cap has the shield.

Cap wins 48-47.

 

[Get To Da Choppa]

Captain America List of Powers and Abilities:

-Superhuman Strength and Speed
-Senses, Agility, and Reflexes enhanced by -Super Soldier serum
-Nearly Indestructible Vibranium Shield
-Master of all forms of hand-to-hand combat
-Superior Strategic Mind


Black Panther List of Powers and Abilities:

-Superhuman Strength and Speed
-Senses, Agility, and Reflexes enhanced by the heart-shaped herb
-Vibranium-laced suit that absorbs, stores, and redirects kinetic energy
-Vibranium Claws
-Brilliant Tactical Mind

Their physical abilities are nearly equal. Cap is stronger but Black Panther is more agile. The outcome of their battle comes down to their equipment. Black Panther’s advanced technology gives him the winning edge.

Chadwick Boseman Black Panther wins.

Shuri Black Panther also wins by girl power

 

[Morning Star]

 

[Sakuraba'sEar]

They're both black now

 

[dildos]

Captain Vietnam would beat both of them.

 

[Thepaintbucket]

In the comic book what's Captain America's greatest strength? His leadership. The MCU version made Steve Rogers overpowered. Black Panther wins if we are talking about the comic book version

 

[mixmastermo]

In the comic book what's Captain's America's greatest strength? His leadership. The MCU version made Steve Rogers overpowered. Black Panther wins if we are talking about the comic book version

Gotta agree with this..

Something they didn't really touch on too much in MCU (although we saw hints of it here and there)

T'Challa is arrogant and when he's mad he gives no fucks. He would straight up maul cap if he is in that kind of mood.

Cap, on the other hand, would want to win clean.

 

[payton]

Panther would emasculate Captain stolen land.

 

[Sweater of AV]

This is like John Stockton vs Orlando Shaq. It's not going to be pretty.

 

[gatchaman]

Going back to Black Panther's first appearance in Fantastic Four #52, Panther was like a Marvel version of Batman. Panther beat the entire FF team because he had prep time. The FF members escaped only because Panther didn't know that they brought Wyatt Wingfoot along.

So, with prep time, Black Panther beats Cap.
Without prep time, it's meta-human (Cap) vs peak human (Panther); Cap wins by super steroids.

Correction: I forgot that Panther is likely also meta-human. It depends on what powers he gets from herbs and Panther God rituals.

 

[Fedorgasm]

Flower power vs the ultimate roider?

Y'know, Panther was a genius even before getting powers.

And cap would likely be a tactical genius even without the super soldier serum. It impacted his body but not his mind.

At the end of the day, Steve Rogers is obsessed with training. The only time he's not training is when he's on an actual mission. I think that gives him the edge over panther.

Panther is a king, so he probably spends a lot of time with his harem. Women weaken legs

 

[SSgt Dickweed]

Depends which side paid off Cecil Peaples more.

 

[LEWIS540]

Which fictional character would win in a 1 vs 1?

Ask he writer. Batman beat Superman, according to Zacharry Snyder, for example.

 

[ChosenOne]

Yes but BP has some good suit tech but then again Cap has the shield.

Cap wins 48-47.

I take the suit over the Shield, any day. The suit seems to absorb any blow the Shield can and while Cap defies physics with his skill in using the shield as an offensive weapon, the suit has offensive capabilities as well,

So with Cap only being peak human, and BP being low level super powered, Cap is forced to make up that gap with superior fight tactics. They are both expert level tacticians, but i do think Cap has a slight edge so that is what makes this one tough. BUt i actually see it slightly different to you.

BP wins 48-47.

 

[Thrawn33]

If you take away the suit and shield: Cap.

All tech in play: BP

 

[KnightTemplar]

Whoever the writer decides.