• Xenforo Cloud is upgrading us to version 2.3.8 on Monday February 16th, 2026 at 12:00 AM PST. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

Can we talk about the LW GOAT???????????????

Let's hold our horses on Khabib GOAT talk until he defends at least once or maybe even more times. I love him in a halal manner but it's to soon to anoint him as the greatest LW. The ride has been great so far but we still need to see him put an irrefutable stamp on the game first by beating at least one real killer like Tony.
 
LW is one of the hardest to pin down. As much as I hate him with every fiber of my hater being, BJ had the legit claim to greatest LW of all time for a number of years. The recent crop of LW champions have some extremely impressive resumes. It's really hard to nail down without a champion with like six plus defenses but that's because LW is the deepest division in MMA bar none. The competition is fiercer than anywhere else and the difference between fighters as razor thin as can be.

Khabibi shouldn't be anywhere near GOAT talks until he's taken out the actual LW champion Conor and the bigger threat in a much more diverse skillset Tony. He runs through them (and I have no doubts he will), slaps around Eddie a couple other LWs, he'll be something to the tune of 30-0 with five defenses. At that point not only will he be the unquestionable LW GOAT but he'll be angling for MMA GOAT if he can match or exceed GSP's title defense record with 0 Ls.
 
Cruz and Alvarez belong on that list
 
*asterisk

I don't usually correct spelling, but it's been spelled wrong three times in 2 different ways and the word is in yellow each time to draw extra attention.

oaoGR_s-200x150.gif
 
You don't become goat by default. When a lightweight (possibly khabib) demonstrates divisional dominance he will be the lightweight goat
 
26-0 is a really good number but Khabib only has 2 really high level wins (Edson and RDA).

All of his other wins range from good/decent to who?

That's not enough for LW GOAT status.
 
If we are excluding Jones (rightfully), then without a doubt Cormier is LHW GOAT. The only other argument is Shogun Rua.

You can't exclude him. He was basically the Jordan of MMA.. And fought in a time where you could get away with a lot. He was using but beating many others also using. He was not a solo cheat. Jones never had any issues with testing before USADA..
 
He can only beat the guys that they let him fight; but he's hardly fought anyone at the top of the division.
 
You can't exclude him. He was basically the Jordan of MMA.. And fought in a time where you could get away with a lot. He was using but beating many others also using. He was not a solo cheat. Jones never had any issues with testing before USADA..

Jordan is not a cheater.

Also DC was clean in the last Jones fight. So that lame excuse "other where using too derp derp" is not valid.
 
Khabib needs to beat a couple more guys first. Alvarez, Ferguson, and Lee are the top matches for him right now. And TJ is not BW GOAT. He lost to the BW GOAT.
 
Jordan is not a cheater.

Also DC was clean in the last Jones fight. So that lame excuse "other where using too derp derp" is not valid.

How the hell do we know Jordan was not a cheater exactly? Because he passed some piddly drug test the NBA gave him. That’s your rationale. During his entire time as champion name me one drug test an athletic commission ever gave him Jones failed?
 
How the hell do we know Jordan was not a cheater exactly? Because he passed some piddly drug test the NBA gave him. That’s your rationale. During his entire time as champion name me one drug test an athletic commission ever gave him Jones failed?

lol
tenor.gif
 
crowning him goat by beating no11 LUL

some ppl around here
 
HW / p4p GOAT thread make over 30 pages.

look like nobody give a shit about LW GOAT.
 
Really good list, OP. But just wondering why isn't Jon Jones LHW GOAT?
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,282,165
Messages
58,420,770
Members
176,033
Latest member
ManoFan
Back
Top