no one is saying he didn't beat him. what we're saying is that it was a shitty fight in which neither guy did anything, not some prodigious performance.
but you're literally ignoring the fact that he was busted for steroids, and spent the next two years coking himself out of his mind and getting morbidly obese. show me an athlete in any sport who came back from a comparable situation, and beaten top opponents upon his return. it doesn't happen because to be at the top, you need to work hard and live like an athlete. he does neither.
when he returns, he will fight a bum and probably win. but as soon as he gets a competent opponent, i expect him to get laid the fuck out, for two reasons: number one, he isn't nearly as good as people make him out to be, despite beating wladimir, and number two, because he's a fat, bipolar cokehead with schizophrenia.