Brazilian Top 10

[DespicablePeep]

Belts for beating soccer moms

 

[SomniumRabidum]

Subjective criteria here, of course, here's my crack at it:

1. Anderson
2. Wand
3. Minotauro
4. Aldo
5. Shogun
6. Werdum
7. Maia
8. Machida
9. Vitor
10. Royce

 

[DespicablePeep]

• How RDA is greater than JDS? Not provoking, just wanna see the arguments.

Longevity and quality wins, I think he is tied with JDS for TD, one each.

 

[mjfan23]

If you include wmma to no top ten list possible without cyborg.

Also Barraro, Arona, filho, jds, rizzo, pele, Ruas, Rickson and busta deserve some consideration in all time Brazilian lists

 

[SomniumRabidum]

If you include wmma to no top ten list possible without cyborg.

Also Barraro, Arona, filho, jds, rizzo, pele, Ruas, Rickson and busta deserve some consideration in all time Brazilian lists

Agree with you on cyborg. I don't like combining lists with WMMA, better to rank them separately imo.

I like most of the guys on your list, but outside of Barao I don't think they're reasonably in the top 10 discussion. Top 15-20 would be a hell of a list though, that's for sure. Get a couple of guys like Lil Nog and Shaolin Ribeiro in there maybe.

 

[1pedestrian]

Belts for beating soccer moms

Belts for beating UFC champions (Tate, Ronda, Schev, Holm, GDR, Cris Cyborg)

 

[Bowel-forged Stool]

She isn’t anywhere near good enough

She got Dat Ass doe, better than juices and excuses in my book

 

[EricSpider]

Longevity and quality wins, I think he is tied with JDS for TD, one each.

Good points. Maybe RDA has more quality wins, but Im more impressed with Junior best wins than I am with Rafael's. The guy beat Stipe, Werdum and prime Cain Velasquez.

 

[Psychojoe86]

JDS belongs on this list! One of the most accomplished mma heavyweights of all time.

 

[JustOnce]

1. Anderson
2. Aldo
3. Big Nog
4 .Nunes
5. Machida
6 .vitor
7.Wand
8. Werdum
9. Shogun

Who should be my 10th fighter ?

what about my list sucks ?
View attachment 823732 View attachment 823733 View attachment 823737 View attachment 823738 View attachment 823739 View attachment 823740

1. Aldo
2. Werdum
3. Shogun
4. Nog
5. Machida
6. Android
7. Trtor
8. Wandy
9. JDS
10. RDA

And Royce probably somewhere depending on how much you value the legacy compared to actual fighting skills

 

[sadoquera]

well, i dont actually see why vitor should be on this list. i mean, he won ufc 7, so it is good, but if u take old era with the modern all together, then royce must be placed as number one. bc other than that, vitor was extremely instable, he won the belt due to a cut, fought 3 times for the belt and was destoyed after brief sprints in the first rounds in all of them. the best part of his career was when he was juiced as fucl. ok, he has a name, but doesnt have a serious resume. thus, considering women, old and modern, i would classify like this:


1. royce (3 times champion, introduced to the world how real fights would be, never lost at his prime, several fights at the same time, all subs, no decisions)
2. nunes (2 division champion, considering the heaviest one, undefeated at her prime, levels above everyone not named valentina)
3. anderson - most title defenses against the better at the time, dominating fights, perfect fighting style
4. aldo - same reason as anderson
5. cyborg - won titles in the heaviest division, undefeated for years, defended most of the belts, levels above everyone not named amanda. would kill valentina
6. werdum - beat fedor and cain (2 that are in all goat talks), ufc champion
7. wand - pride run
8. machida - great legacy, won belt, fought for the belt in the division below
9. JDS - craziest hw run ever
10. shogun - pride 2006 / ufc gold, his resume at one night beats rda resume in several nights