Bjj or Karate need input

G

Ghostdogg

Blue Belt
Joined
Jun 18, 2008
Messages
713
Reaction score
0
This is my first post so bare with me. I decided to start ma this year and I have a friend who fights in mma local stuff and he goes to a karate school. The teacher is very good nice guy he has black belts in a few styles (shotkan,kempo,jujitsu) and I have been going for a few months now, and I feel I learned a few things, but then I found out about a gracie barra school thats closer to my home and here is where my prob started. I really like jujitsu u get to spare/roll first class, my karate class still havent sparred. My goal is to do some tournaments get into better shape and learn a style that I could use In a real fight If somone could give some input that would be great. I went to the bjj school teacher is a good guy and he is a black belt. so my question is should I do bjj or ecletic karate.
 
BJJ...you spar every class, there's always competitions/tournaments, you'll get into great shape.

Deciding to start BJJ is one of the best things I've ever done for myself.
 
I think it depends on what you really plan to get out of your martial arts experience. Obviously you might find people a little biased here on the grappling forum. If you had to choose between the two, you should go with BJJ. If it's a legit gracie barra school the instruction will likely be good, and you will learn a lot.

As far as self defense goes BJJ > Karate but it might be good to take some boxing courses somewhere too. After all BJJ is great if you can get the fight to the ground, or you are lucky enough to lock up a standing position. However, I've found that it's not as effective if you get knocked out because you don't know how to cover up and avoid punches.
 
Any guy who boasts multiple black belts is always sketchy, takes two years to (for the average person) even be accustomed to just the basics of any martial art (you could argue six months for Boxing) and even if the guy's legit in multiple martial arts, it's very difficult to pass down multiple styles at the same time, so much info, how are you actually going be decent at them?

as for BJJ....very competition oriented, it'll definitely make you stronger, i couldn't do a pushup in HS but then i started grappling in college that all changed, as for self-defense, BJJ should protect you from anything other than multiple opponents and knives/firearms (no martial art is a substitute for common sense)
 
I think BJJ is probably more fun for a beginner, but I wouldn't rule out the karate at all. I train in both, though it helps that my karate sensei is really into MMA and picks up all the little tricks and such from pretty much every art. As for which is better in a fight...it really depends on how that particular school trains. Just decide which one feels right to you, it'll be the correct decision.
 
If it's kyokushin or an offshot, you could do both.
But shotokan.. Go with BJJ
 
well what he has done is taken all the things he has learned from the multiple styles and formed one single style using the best part from each. And the bjj is what it is and it is legit it is daniel gracie jujitsu who is a part of team renzo gracie. I have seen pro's and cons to both but like somoen else wrote im just alittle skeptikal on the whole hybrid karate and The teacher is legit in his fighting skill but just cuz he is good doesnt mean he can make others good and like i said he is gonna give u 1 option to his 3 or 4 options do to mulitple style mastery.
 
For what it's worth, I spent almost 18 years training and teaching in a traditional karate style, and acheived rank as a 4th degree black belt. However, once I discovered grappling/BJJ, I began training it more and more to the point where I closed down my school, stopped training in my previous style, and began training BJJ full time. I now have much more confidence in my ability to defend myself in a realistic self-defense situation, and feel a much greater sense of accomplishment in obtaining a purple belt in BJJ than I did in obtaining a 4th degree black belt in karate.

I'm not saying that there is necessarily anything wrong with karate as a whole. It depends upon what your purpose for training is. However, for realistic training, it's hard to beat the "liveness" of BJJ. You know that if you can pull off the techniques against a fully resisting opponent who knows what you are trying to do, if will be much easier to do this with an untrained person. You have confidence that the techniques will work because you've performed them in a "live" situation. This is something that you don't get in a lot of more traditional styles that revolve primarily around kata or point-style sparring. If you want to practice striking too, I would suggest something like boxing, muay thai, or one of the full contact versions of karate, like kyokushin or something like that.

The other thing that really intrigues me about grappling is that the game is constantly evolving. People are constantly working on creating new positions/submissions, etc. It never gets old or stale.
 
use in a fight; both can be useful, but it will prolly hit the ground: bjj

get in shape: i did tae kwan do for 8 years and was over weight. started bjj, lost 25 pounds in under a year.

bjj wins
 
Karate is great to brush up on choreography and such... In real fighting, going to the ground is almost always something that's likely to happen, especially if you intend to make it happen, in which case, BJJ is your best option...
 
Sub Dude said:
For what it's worth, I spent almost 18 years training and teaching in a traditional karate style, and acheived rank as a 4th degree black belt. However, once I discovered grappling/BJJ, I began training it more and more to the point where I closed down my school, stopped training in my previous style, and began training BJJ full time. I now have much more confidence in my ability to defend myself in a realistic self-defense situation, and feel a much greater sense of accomplishment in obtaining a purple belt in BJJ than I did in obtaining a 4th degree black belt in karate.

I'm not saying that there is necessarily anything wrong with karate as a whole. It depends upon what your purpose for training is. However, for realistic training, it's hard to beat the "liveness" of BJJ. You know that if you can pull off the techniques against a fully resisting opponent who knows what you are trying to do, if will be much easier to do this with an untrained person. You have confidence that the techniques will work because you've performed them in a "live" situation. This is something that you don't get in a lot of more traditional styles that revolve primarily around kata or point-style sparring. If you want to practice striking too, I would suggest something like boxing, muay thai, or one of the full contact versions of karate, like kyokushin or something like that.

The other thing that really intrigues me about grappling is that the game is constantly evolving. People are constantly working on creating new positions/submissions, etc. It never gets old or stale.
Click to expand...

Now that I think about it, I used to find myself making a lot of excuses for things and saying the same stuff that my karate instructors used to tell me like: "that technique is too dangerous to demonstrate for real", "you're not ready to learn that technique yet", and trying to find "secret" meanings and applications for outdated techniques that would make them more "effective".....now, when someone questions a technique, it's real simple. Get on the mat and try it out. If I submit you with it, well then, I'd say it's pretty effective!! Overall, I feel that my time now is spent training in a much more legit system. Wish I'd made the switch earlier than I did.
 
BJJ. But this is the grappling forum :)

And as has been said, grappling gets you in a lot better shape alot quicker
 
BJJ for single opponents & I would recommend Escrima (stick fighting) for a realistic situation involving multiple attackers.
 
Don't you think asking this question in a grappling forum is going to generate an obvious bias?

Not that I disagree that BJJ is superior, it clearly is. Just something I had to point out.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,246,370
Messages
56,118,183
Members
175,074
Latest member
former lurker

Share this page

Back
Top