Big fights with polemic decisions. Which ones do you agree or disagree with?

[Kung Fu bb]

Machida vs Shogun I

Jones vs Gustafsson

Penn vs Edgar I

TJ vs Dom

Edgar vs Henderson

Bisping vs Dan

Diaz vs Conor II

 

[Substance Abuse]

Shogun, Jones, Penn, Dom, Bendo, Bisping, Conor.

 

[Arm Barbarian]

Nick Diaz vs Condit.

Never heard the end of that one.

 

[Gregoire1]

Gus vs DC

 

[executionermma]

Shogun, Jones, Penn, Dom, Edgar, Bisping, Conor

 

[quantiqus]

Machida vs Shogun I

Jones vs Gustafsson

Penn vs Edgar I

TJ vs Dom

Edgar vs Henderson

Bisping vs Dan

Diaz vs Conor II

Shogun - yes, I agree

Jones - it could have been a draw, same as for DC vs Gus, but not a win for Gus

BJ - I don't remember the fight, I will watch it

TJ - draw. Cruz didn't win that

Egar - yes, I agree, he won that one

Hendo - I agree, he won

Conor - no (and I dislike Conor), he had 3 knockdowns. Diaz had more punches and you could say that that shit was refusing to engage in the fight, though.

Nick Diaz vs Condit.

Never heard the end of that one.

You can say that about most decision fights.
Condit won that fight.
I know that people here believe he wasn't the real NBK because he refused to play Diaz's game, but who did play Diaz's game? Diego Sanchez?

 

[executionermma]

TJ - draw. Cruz didn't win that.

Explain. How it is a draw? 10-10 rounds are stupid, someone was better, it can be by a punch but someone has to be ahead when you take all criterias in consideration. Either Cruz won or TJ won, since there were no 10-8 rounds. It only depends to who you scored the first round, the most competitive one. I did for Cruz, so he won r1/r2/r3, 48-47.

 

[JAGDPANZER209]

Cruz won that shit

 

[Szwok]

rampage vs forest belongs here

 

[Pakman]

most of these fights were close. The Machida vs Shogun fight was the biggest robbery of them all i think. But it was a close fight.

Where is Bisping vs Matt Hamil ? Any Leonard Garcia fight?

 

[bambammccoy]

rampage vs forest belongs here

You'e joking right?

 

[Kassitus]

I disagree with all the official results except Bisping and Dom winning.

 

[Szwok]

You'e joking right?

joking how? Forest won but even when that 2nd round wouldve been 10-8 i see rampage winning.

 

[ghoul]

Machida, Jones, Edgar, Dom, Edgar Bisping, Conor
Close fights.

 

[Not Tuf]

The ones I have strong opions on are
Shogun should have gotten the nod over machida. It is like the judges in that fight didn't score kicks.
Jones beat Gus and I think the arguments for Gus are based on the bias that he was not destroyed.
I had Penn beating Edgar in the first fight.
Diaz Conor 2 I scored a draw.

 

[Not Tuf]

most of these fights were close. The Machida vs Shogun fight was the biggest robbery of them all i think. But it was a close fight.

Where is Bisping vs Matt Hamil ? Any Leonard Garcia fight?

If I remember right Bisping Hamil and any Leonard Garcia fight were just straight up robberies. Hard to even call them controversial instead of wrong.

 

[DarkneT]

Machida and Shogun really wasn't that bad

People that harp on about how bad it was probably never watched it


The worst decision I've seen in over 12 years of watching MMA
Is very recent
And it was Hendo Bisping 2

 

[Codpiece]

joking how? Forest won but even when that 2nd round wouldve been 10-8 i see rampage winning.

When I watched that fight years ago I had the impression Rampage won it. When I rewatched it I thought Forrest won fairly obviously.


OT:

Shogun
Gus or draw
Penn
Cruz (juuuust)
Bendo
Bisping (wanted Hendo to win)
Conor

 

[Gorkle]

the worst decision I've seen in over 12 years of watching MMA
Is very recent
And it was Hendo Bisping 2

You must not watch much MMA then.

 

[fortheo]

Machida and Shogun really wasn't that bad

People that harp on about how bad it was probably never watched it


The worst decision I've seen in over 12 years of watching MMA
Is very recent
And it was Hendo Bisping 2

Have you seen Diego Sanchez vs. Ross Pearson? Or Sanchez vs. Gomi?