- Joined
- Jun 7, 2015
- Messages
- 22,046
- Reaction score
- 12,211
I would have loved to see the same leeway from you with the Last Jedi.
Depends on what we vibe with it seems.
Liked the movie just didn't love it.. from my point a view a 7/10 is a fair score and I'm not deep into the MCU all things considered, I only have a little over a handful of movies that I do care to revisit.
Conversely, I'm surprised by you and Secret Agent's thoughts on this movie considering your opinions and defenses on TLJ.
I don't expect everyone to give the movie a 10 out of 10, and that's not what I'm trying to convince you of here, but your reasoning behind scoring the way that you did had nothing to do with what was actually seen in the movie. Criticizing the movie on what iMDB says about an actor's contract, or what movie a studio has in production should have no bearing on your thoughts of what actually happens in a movie.
I don't see myself giving any "leeway" to this movie. Because I don't think the story of IW was poor. It was a story that was set up over multiple movies and then executed damn near perfectly in IW. It's actually interesting that there are a few parallels between this movie and TLJ, which puzzles me even more that you could have negative thoughts on this one, and maintain positive ones on TLJ.
Both movies are sequels with a large cast on different missions in diffferent parts of the galaxy, they are products of a universe of other movies, and they were both directed by a different director from the previous movie. Putting these movies side by side, I don't see how you can not see how IW hit it out of the park, and TLJ failed miserably.
I didn't give TLJ any leeway because it didn't deserve any. The Russos cooridinated with the directors of the other Marvel movies. They worked together to understand what was the vision for those characters, their personalities, and where they saw them going in the future. They also didn't ignore or try to erase things established in previous movies. Johnson acted as if TFA didn't exist. That resulted in a disjointed story from what we knew of in TFA, and the rest of the SW movies. Uneven tone. Weak characters with unknown, or flimsy motivations...none of that was in IW.