Asher Susser talks about the changing Arab world and Israel

jeffk

Brown Belt
@Brown
Joined
May 21, 2007
Messages
4,448
Reaction score
417
This guy almost always gives good talks.

I'll try to brief and summarize some of his ideas in the first half of his talk.

- Even the problems of Syria go away tomorrow, there is going to be a flood of refugees from the Arab states to Europe. There is a huge population increase and not enough jobs.

- Arabism - the idea that Arabs will unite together and that will be more important than states hasn't recovered since the 1967 War when Israel won in 6 days. Israel hasn't recovered from the win but that is discussed later.

- If Arabism is a failure, why go the political Islamist route instead of going for Marxism or other ideology?
Culture matters. The Arab world is big on tradition and resistant to change because they don't have the separation of religion and state, the Middle East is a society where people are members of a group, not individuals, reform has almost always been imposed from the top down. It hasn't been organic and grown from the people.

The consequence of recent history - disintegration of some Arab states, the rise of Iran's power and influence

Israel's founding fathers were paranoid about Arab states aligning with USSR and becoming and overwhelmingly powerful conventional force so Israel developed nuclear weapons. But the bigger threat to Israel today comes from non-state actor and Iran. Israel now has common interests to align with Arab states to deal with Iran or its proxies or groups like ISIS.

And that was just the first half

 
Nothing he has said is new. These state of affairs have repeated itself throughout history with different players each time. And I did not even watch the vid, but trust me.
 
Sounds like good stuff. Will try to watch tomorrow. Thanks.
 
The second half he talks about Israel. He says Israel hasn't recovered from winning the 1967 war.

A state has a central authority and borders. Israel doesn't not have domestically or internationally recognized borders and the settlers don't accept the central authority.

He worries Jews in Israel are going back to old traditions and going to lose their secular values and their value of having a state. The Arabs may be a lesser threat than damage Israel does that is self-inflected by providing support for settlements and for providing welfare to religious folks whose spend all day studying religion and don't do much for the state. They are not taught marketable skills in their schools. Israelis in Israel proper get less services because of the money and resources spent on the settlement enterprises and religious folks.
 
Back
Top