After her win tonight, would you like to see Rose vs Joanna 3?

[egk]

Two wins is nice, but there's no changing the fact that she had a title shot already very recently and lost badly. Both Andrade and Karolina have similar claims to title shots, and neither of them are particularly strong. All you've shown so far is hate and bias. The fact your comparisons you've shown are absolutely ridiculous. Lol, comparing her to Brock. Please, tell me when the Andrade fight will guarantee 1.5+ mil PPV buys and that fight would be guaranteed lol.

If all I've shown is hate and bias, all you've shown is a propensity to kiss ass and make excuses.
Two wins is nice, yes. It's actually one more than Rose had and against higher ranked opponents. I don't think 14 months ago is that recent. Not in the UFC.
Brock was an example. I know exactly why he's getting a title shot but no one can claim he deserves it. Yet you're sitting there smugly claiming Andrade doesn't deserve it after knocking off two of the top fiive while she's ranked #2? Who does deserve one then? Does Till deserve a title shot off of missing weight? Did Gustafsson deserve a title shot after being knocked the fuck out by Rumble? The UFC is rife with that kind of thing.

 

[randumo24]

I'm including good grapplers as wrestlers because takedowns and ground fighting is what they're best at and what they try to do. Andrade, Gadelha, Esparza, Herrig and now Suarez. That's 5 of the top 10. Rose hasn't fought any of them except when she lost the TUF finale to Esparza

Except that's not true. 2 of the 3 fighters she fought on TUF were good grapplers, and she subbed both of them. The last one being the next best to Carla, who beat Herrig with her wrestling lol.

 

[egk]

Except that's not true. 2 of the 3 fighters she fought on TUF were good grapplers, and she subbed both of them. The last one being the next best to Carla, who beat Herrig with her wrestling lol.

I said she's never fought any in the top 10. Somehow she's still never been matched up with any of them except Esparza who she had to fight. Preferential matchmaking, maybe? nahhhh. In the UFC? Impossible!

 

[randumo24]

If all I've shown is hate and bias, all you've shown is a propensity to kiss ass and make excuses.
Two wins is nice, yes. It's actually one more than Rose had and against higher ranked opponents. I don't think 14 months ago is that recent. Not in the UFC.
Brock was an example. I know exactly why he's getting a title shot but no one can claim he deserves it. Yet you're sitting there smugly claiming Andrade doesn't deserve it after knocking off two of the top fiive while she's ranked #2? Who does deserve one then? Does Till deserve a title shot off of missing weight? Did Gustafsson deserve a title shot after being knocked the fuck out by Rumble? The UFC is rife with that kind of thing.

What's really funny is Andrade said herself that she had to do more to prove she deserved a title shot after the Torres fight. Two decision victories after getting dominated in her title shot is hardly screaming of being worthy of a title shot. She even said herself, if she wanted to prove she deserved another title shot right now that she had to finish the fight.

 

[SuperNerd]

No not yet

 

[egk]

What's really funny is Andrade said herself that she had to do more to prove she deserved a title shot after the Torres fight. Two decision victories after getting dominated in her title shot is hardly screaming of being worthy of a title shot. She even said herself, if she wanted to prove she deserved another title shot right now that she had to finish the fight.

So who deserves one then? Joanna obviously doesn't. How long does the top 5 beat each other up while waiting for Rose?

 

[Vegesus44]

That would be a hard no.

 

[Dbreiden83080]

No but Rose better get it together and defend soon. We don’t need another champion sitting on a belt. And she needs to strike when the momentum is with her. She could become a huge star but she has to be active.

 

[Amygdala]

I’d like to see them take other fights first before a rematch. (And — super unpopular opinion— but I had JJ pretty much winning that second fight. Seemed to me like everyone expected Rose to win, then just filled in the narrative and ignored a lot of the nice work JJ did with sneaky knees and such. Never rewatched though.)

 

[randumo24]

So who deserves one then? Joanna obviously doesn't. How long does the top 5 beat each other up while waiting for Rose?

The winner of the Andrade/Karolina fight. That would be another win for Andrade if she wins, which even a decision would be a 3rd one. Karolina, while slightly lower ranked, has the added claim of being the last one to beat Rose(despite the extenuating circumstances). Having this fight be a number 1 contenders match makes for a more clear and earned contenders match, and a more marketable fight either way. As of right now, Karolina would obviously be the more marketable fight because of the rematch but she's below on the rankings. Blame JJ for making it so nobody really particularly deserves a title shot right now.

 

[TheRealWill]

No way.

 

[Dorkman]

She had her immediate rematch after being trounced, and still didn't get the W. That's where you go to the back of the line or wait until someone else takes the belt off of her.

 

[Swarthy]

She had her immediate rematch after being trounced, and still didn't get the W. That's where you go to the back of the line or wait until someone else takes the belt off of her.

I think she won. But I agree she should not get a shot untill either she gets a undeniable streak together or Rose loses the belt.

I was not for the re-match btw Unless it is a draw or split and super close Ie Franky vs Bendo, WB vs Woodley 1 The ex champ should go away for a bit.

Imo Gus vs JBJ shoulda been a re-match straight away.

 

[randumo24]

Honestly, the only thing she has to do if she wants to get a rematch is admit Rose is the better fighter. If she can't do that, and Rose successfully defends her title in the next fight, JJ should just move up to 125. There's no reason she should be getting a 3rd shot at Rose, and she's beaten everyone else in the division really. She doesn't deserve another shot at Rose, and there's no point in sticking around in her position if she can't be competing for the title.

 

[legcramp]