• Xenforo Cloud is upgrading us to version 2.3.8 on Monday February 16th, 2026 at 12:00 AM PST. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

Sherdog vs Reddit r/MMA vs MMA Underground

ProPROpro

Purple Belt
@purple
Joined
May 8, 2010
Messages
2,244
Reaction score
876
Match/Brawl includes one message board vs opposing message board, winner board fights winner board for ultra tournament championship title. Match takes place in Mandalay Bay general audience seating and can progress into the octagon / yamma pit.

Rules:
-No weapons
-No professional combat athletes
-No USADA testing
-Ref - Mario Yamasaki
-Open weight
-Co-ed
-One round
-No time limit

No belt awarded, only honor

Who wins?

{<Scared}<{UberTS}><{JustBleed}>:meow:
 
I give Sherdog the heght, reach, and hairline advantage.
 
Reddit MMA are the biggest cucks on the internet. Sherdog is a true representation into the mind of the MMA fan

Also we're all 6'7 270 5% body fat so fuck them
 
Well this isn't even a contest. This is the average reddit user:
man-on-couch-watching-tv.jpg


This is the average sherdog user:
upload_2019-12-27_18-37-51.png

And MMA underground? <FookIsThatGuy>
 
are you asking which group of armchair warriors would perform better in a fight?
 
I cant stand reddits format. It feels like the 1990's, which is the worst era of the internet, as far as usability goes.
 
The underground is dead, bunch of has been trying to keep a sinking ship alive. r/mma was the final nail in the coffin.

Also the bitches here shit talking r/mma. I don't see motherfuckers here posting HD streamable links to knockouts and finishes right as the fights end.

r/mma is just a more civilized mma discussion board. Sherdog is the cesspool of MMA.
 
I’m on team shitdog

So.. we win I’m alpha AF bruh
 
Reddit is where dumb people go to pretend they're smart.

Sherdog is where smart people go to pretend they're dumb.
 
l7i04vfih1531.png


Is this thread serious? The average Sherdogger could KO 100 Redditors with a fart.
 
are you asking which group of armchair warriors would perform better in a fight?

Yes, which group would win. Match takes place 1v1 message board style. Winner fights winner for ultra champions of honor title.
 
Reddit MMA are the biggest cucks on the internet. Sherdog is a true representation into the mind of the MMA fan

Also we're all 6'7 270 5% body fat so fuck them

I do think Sherdog has a deeper, more nuanced view of combat athletics overall.
 
Stupid question... sherdoggers win easily.

Here are the FACTS we know:

Sherdoggers range from anything between 6'7'' too 8'3''. 6'7'' being the very minimum, I personally am 7'8''

Sherdoggers typically hover in and around the 570 Ibs range, with 1% body fat.

And then you have to factor in other things like our weightlifting....

Sherdogger max bench press: 2,850 Ibs
Sherdogger max deadlift: 3,200 Ibs

Its not really close.
 
I cant stand reddits format. It feels like the 1990's, which is the worst era of the internet, as far as usability goes.
Plenty of apps that help the format. Their official app and website sucks but boost and Apollo are pretty good. Boost is my favorite, it's runs reddit almost like a facebook timeline.
 
Reddit is fucking trash in the comments literally nothing but casuals and conor nuthuggers sherdog is my shit !!! Sherbros for life
 
Stupid question... sherdoggers win easily.

Here are the FACTS we know:

Sherdoggers range from anything between 6'7'' too 8'3''. 6'7'' being the very minimum, I personally am 7'8''

Sherdoggers typically hover in and around the 570 Ibs range, with 1% body fat.

And then you have to factor in other things like our weightlifting....

Sherdogger max bench press: 2,850 Ibs
Sherdogger max deadlift: 3,200 Ibs

Its not really close.

I set a new PR every week on either bench, squat, or clean and press. Sometimes it seems too easy
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,281,584
Messages
58,377,268
Members
176,017
Latest member
KTFOPerformance
Back
Top