Sherdog Ranks Ilia #2 P4P

10000yearsold

Brown Belt
@Brown
Joined
Jul 17, 2021
Messages
2,952
Reaction score
3,253
I find this to be a pretty shocking event. All we’ve really seen displayed by Ilia is extraordinary knockout power for his weight class. There’s nothing p4p great IMO about being the hardest puncher at FW.

My understanding of P4P is an athlete displaying a skill set that transcends the context of the playing field merely within their weight class. It has most often been the reward of successful results venturing out into weight classes beyond the one they dominate. Ilia has in no way showcased this in any manner other than talk that transcends his stature.

If anyone should have gotten a p4p bump, it should be Khamzat who has successfully shown dominance as a top title picture fighter now in two weight classes with a broad skill set encompassing impressive feats of striking success and extraordinary exhibitions of grappling.

Ilia says he can grapple, but he has very sparingly applied this and to no great impression that it has any great significance for dealing with an opponent for whom that is their strong suit.

This is a case of putting a fighters hype and promise before their accomplishments. Pretty petty ass kissery of the official promotional narrative it seems. No way this guy is even top 5 p4p in my book.
 
P4P chatter? Man you guys are suckers…what a ludicrous concept that gets argued about daily here.

<36>
 
Poatan
Jones
Illa
Dricus
Belal

Would be how i rank the top 5
 
Islam
Ilia
Jones

Are my undisputable top 3 as in if everybody were the same size, and all around skilled mma fighters. Poatan is the best striker by far but if he was the same size as Islam or Ilia he’d get destroyed
 
Meh, I never put much weight into the whole pound for pound thing, At the end of the day, there are the divisional champs and the order you put them in is just your preference.
 
Last edited:
Off the top of my head, I’d have it:

1 Jones
2 Islam
3 Dricus
4 Poatan
5 Aspinal
6 Merab
7 Topuria
8 Belal
9 Volkanovski
10 khamzat

Other worthy mentions: Pantoja, Sterling, Strickand, Adesanya, Holloway
 
P4P is as fake as the coronavirus.
popcorn-eating.gif
 
I have it

1. Pereira
2. Islam
3. Jones
4. Topuria
5. Belal

*** Jones should be dropped due to being inactive

Here are the rankings

Why would belal or islam be over dricus who has never lost in the UFC and has beaten 3 of the best fighters of his generation in Izzy, Whittaker and strickland? all recently?

Serious question. Belal has losses to people still ranked in the UFC like geoff neal.
 
If you think its just punching power you have zero idea what you are watching.
 
All of you are not membering the name, ya know the most fan-friendly fighter at 170 that Dana said was bigger than soccer. That guy come when he's about to fight will be number 1 pfp. It changes with whos on the next PPV.
 
Back
Top