San Francisco prosecutor won't charge man (Self-defense)

[oldshadow]

San Francisco prosecutor won't charge man accused in 2013 baseball game stabbing

Prosecutors have decided not to prosecute a man in the stabbing death of a Dodger's fan during an altercation after a Los Angeles-San Francisco baseball game last year.

District Attorney George Gascon said in a statement Friday that prosecutors wouldn't file charges against Michael Montgomery because they didn't believe they had enough evidence to prove that Montgomery didn't act in self-defense when he killed Jonathan Denver.

Should there be calls for laws to ban the caring of all knifes? After all if he had not had a knife then he could have just taken his beating like a man, so what if he was severely beating and permanently injured or killed. He could have taken it like a man.

If he had not had the knife would he have been so confident as to get in an argument with the other guys.

(Note I do agree getting into a fight over a team is stupid in the first place, but shit happens)

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2014/03/2...e-man-accused-in-2013-baseball-game-stabbing/

http://www.usnews.com/news/sports/articles/2014/03/21/no-charges-filed-in-baseball-stabbing

 

[bigconan]

Should there be calls for laws to ban the caring of all knifes? After all if he had not had a knife then he could have just taken his beating like a man, so what if he was severely beating and permanently injured or killed. He could have taken it like a man.

If he had not had the knife would he have been so confident as to get in an argument with the other guys.

(Note I do agree getting into a fight over a team is stupid in the first place, but shit happens)

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2014/03/2...e-man-accused-in-2013-baseball-game-stabbing/

http://www.usnews.com/news/sports/articles/2014/03/21/no-charges-filed-in-baseball-stabbing

You say he should have just taken his beating? Are you nuts? We all have a right to defend ourselves in anyway we see fit. If a person feels his well being could be affected, we all have a right to use whatever means to not allow that to happen.

 

[Queen B]

You say he should have just taken his beating? Are you nuts? We all have a right to defend ourselves in anyway we see fit. If a person feels his well being could be affected, we all have a right to use whatever means to not allow that to happen.

Agreed. Similar to Zimmerman/Trayvon case.

Zimmerman's life was being threatened, so Zimmerman had every right to unload bullets on Trayvon

 

[oldshadow]

You say he should have just taken his beating? Are you nuts? We all have a right to defend ourselves in anyway we see fit. If a person feels his well being could be affected, we all have a right to use whatever means to not allow that to happen.

Should have put

 

[sangreporsangre]

Well since you already said ban knives in the OP I don't know what else you really wanna hear. Usually threads like this are just a "ban knives" circle jerk until Big D or some European poster shows up to troll you

 

[oldshadow]

Well since you already said ban knives in the OP I don't know what else you really wanna hear. Usually threads like this are just a "ban knives" circle jerk until Big D or some European poster shows up to troll you

I

 

[jefferz]

Well since you already said ban knives in the OP I don't know what else you really wanna hear. Usually threads like this are just a "ban knives" circle jerk until Big D or some European poster shows up to troll you

And right after Big D comes in Scrody will be right behind him, then they can start there usual school yard name insulting.

 

[UpaLoompa]

Posting so maybe I can remember this for the next time we get threads about how awful California is. I'll keep it with my 9th circuit progun rulings.

 

[Lord of Lies]

And once again, we see that LA fans are douche bags. Good thing the guy defended himself and didn't end up like that Giants fan a couple of years ago.

 

[Social Distance Warrior]

I'll go ahead and expedite this entire thread.

WE should ban knives.

no, Ban baseball.

no, ban drunken idiot dodger fans.

Guns are bad.

Guns are good.

If we ban guns, the government will run wild and the military will take over the country like what Pol Pot, Mao, Stalin did.

etc etc

 

[oldshadow]

I'll go ahead and expedite this entire thread.

WE should ban knives.

no, Ban baseball.

no, ban drunken idiot dodger fans.

Guns are bad.

Guns are good.

If we ban guns, the government will run wild and the military will take over the country like what Pol Pot, Mao, Stalin did.

etc etc

Yea but it

 

[Seph]

Yes making a stupid and incendiary arguments for gun rights does wonders for the cause and the stereotype of all gun owners being idiot uneducated rednecks.

 

[ben236]

 

[Scrody]

You say he should have just taken his beating? Are you nuts? We all have a right to defend ourselves in anyway we see fit. If a person feels his well being could be affected, we all have a right to use whatever means to not allow that to happen.

It doesn't matter. Anyone that pulls a knife over a tiny fist fight is a pussy. Why not just yell for the police? It's at a baseball game, they can't be far away. You take your licks like a man, it don't matter how old you are, you fight the fucking douche bag, you don't kill him. What kind of society would allow people to carry knives in public?

 

[Scrody]

And right after Big D comes in Scrody will be right behind him, then they can start there usual school yard name insulting.

Hey, don't mention us in the same sentence for Christ's sake.

 

[jlagman]

Calling for immediate bans are too drastic and make double-standards too evident. A knife registry and buy back program should suffice, for now...

 

[Tension]

It doesn't matter. Anyone that pulls a knife over a tiny fist fight is a pussy. Why not just yell for the police? It's at a baseball game, they can't be far away. You take your licks like a man, it don't matter how old you are, you fight the fucking douche bag, you don't kill him. What kind of society would allow people to carry knives in public?

lol. My number one goal is to keep living, anything happens on the street and all of this fair rules fight like a man bullshit goes out the window.

 

[Scrody]

lol. My number one goal is to keep living, anything happens on the street and all of this fair rules fight like a man bullshit goes out the window.

Personally, I think society would be better off without the need for violence. But that's how it is. Why assume anyone looking to fight over being fans of a particular team is looking to kill you? This guy was a sissy that was just looking for an excuse to stick someone, maybe even kill him. BS IMO.

 

[Bukowski82]

You say he should have just taken his beating? Are you nuts? We all have a right to defend ourselves in anyway we see fit. If a person feels his well being could be affected, we all have a right to use whatever means to not allow that to happen.

lol, sarcasm detector needs batteries Bruh

 

[oldshadow]

Yes making a stupid and incendiary arguments for gun rights does wonders for the cause and the stereotype of all gun owners being idiot uneducated rednecks.

Where in this thread has that happened?