- Joined
- Apr 9, 2007
- Messages
- 52,978
- Reaction score
- 25,404
https://www.mediaite.com/podcasts/t...rmed-theory-that-covid-leaked-from-wuhan-lab/
Interview link below
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-interview/id1527832549
- Back in March , former CDC director and virologist Dr. Robert Redfield, stated to CNN correspondent Dr. Sanjay Gupta that he belives the virus came from the Wuhan Institute of Virology. He didn't have direct evidence, so this was just his professional opinion.
- Dr. Redfield was attacked for saying this.
- Well recently Dr. Sanjay Gupta gave an interview on Mediate.
- In the Mediate interview, Dr. Gupta says Dr. Redfied's opinion is an informed opinion.
“He’s an experienced virologist. He was also head of the CDC at the time this was happening, which means that in addition to everything that we know, he had access to raw data and raw intelligence that was coming out of China,” Gupta told me. “My point is that it’s a much more informed sort of thing for him to be saying than for anybody who may have expertise in virology, because he has a lot more knowledge and information that he has that maybe he can’t share, but is informing his opinion.”
Gupta said he offered Redfield opportunities to hedge his opinion, but that the former CDC director “really was quite adamant that this was the origin of the virus.”
--
Dr. Gupta's comments also leans towards believing this was a lab escape.
“There’s reason to suspect that this is the origin of the virus,” Gupta said, pointing out the flaws in the predominant theory that it came from a wet market.
“It’s a big virology lab right in Wuhan that happened to be studying bat coronaviruses. Just from an Occam’s razor standpoint, finding the simplest explanation, it would make sense,” he said, adding, “We still don’t know for certain what the origin is.”
---
@panamaican the reason I didn't make this post in the other thread by @DespicablePeep is because this thread is narrowly focused on Sanjay Gupta's comments, while the other thread is more broadly a criticism of academic community rushing to claim the virus was a natural spill over. These comments from Gupta would just get lost if I had made it in that thread.
Interview link below
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-interview/id1527832549
- Back in March , former CDC director and virologist Dr. Robert Redfield, stated to CNN correspondent Dr. Sanjay Gupta that he belives the virus came from the Wuhan Institute of Virology. He didn't have direct evidence, so this was just his professional opinion.
- Dr. Redfield was attacked for saying this.
- Well recently Dr. Sanjay Gupta gave an interview on Mediate.
- In the Mediate interview, Dr. Gupta says Dr. Redfied's opinion is an informed opinion.
“He’s an experienced virologist. He was also head of the CDC at the time this was happening, which means that in addition to everything that we know, he had access to raw data and raw intelligence that was coming out of China,” Gupta told me. “My point is that it’s a much more informed sort of thing for him to be saying than for anybody who may have expertise in virology, because he has a lot more knowledge and information that he has that maybe he can’t share, but is informing his opinion.”
Gupta said he offered Redfield opportunities to hedge his opinion, but that the former CDC director “really was quite adamant that this was the origin of the virus.”
--
Dr. Gupta's comments also leans towards believing this was a lab escape.
“There’s reason to suspect that this is the origin of the virus,” Gupta said, pointing out the flaws in the predominant theory that it came from a wet market.
“It’s a big virology lab right in Wuhan that happened to be studying bat coronaviruses. Just from an Occam’s razor standpoint, finding the simplest explanation, it would make sense,” he said, adding, “We still don’t know for certain what the origin is.”
---
@panamaican the reason I didn't make this post in the other thread by @DespicablePeep is because this thread is narrowly focused on Sanjay Gupta's comments, while the other thread is more broadly a criticism of academic community rushing to claim the virus was a natural spill over. These comments from Gupta would just get lost if I had made it in that thread.
Last edited:
