- Joined
- Feb 22, 2005
- Messages
- 52,840
- Reaction score
- 28,986
In lieu of Pugilistic's thread about the cognitive aspects of training, it spurred me to make this thread which I'd already thought about for a little while on the differences of bag work. This is one of those subjects where I really explored the notion of "why?" People hit bags, but are they really positive of what they're training? Do the skills translate to moving combat? Is anyone supervising and if so, what exactly are they supervising? I'll show some examples of supervised bag work, and drills, some of them will be footage you may have seen before, but in this light more will be observable about what's going on.
First is Kolli's bag work. This session was a good one for two reasons, one is it alerted me to a mistake he'd been repeating that I'd seen but not paid enough heed to. Second is he was tired, and he knew he was going to struggle with form in the last round or two. Kolli's a good thinker in the ring, so what I try to do is give him ideas:
I really like that last round, because he learned the concept of bullshitting in the ring. Making it look like you're working harder than you are. A practice that suits his personality well.
Next up is Art, with two different types of bags and different reasons they're used. Art is also a thinking man, so he doesn't need to be babysat. Just basic corrections and he can run with it:
When supervising bag work with a person who has some experience it's less about repetition (repetition happens on its own, it doesn't need to be harped on), and more about what to do and when, then let them play with it. It's also how you spot thinking weaknesses in fighters. A robotic guy will just blast away at the bag over and over again. They'll naturally fall into drilling. But the drilling should facilitate technique:
The above fighter is a bit robotic in nature. The kind of kid who doesn't think deep thoughts in the middle of a task. More of a workhorse who needs to be given tools (he won't invent anything). So you gotta use drills like the above footage before you try to get him to think creatively. He'll first learn to do it out of necessity, when exhausted, when the roboticness is beaten out of him. Then you can give him more adaptive free-form exercises:
This is to demonstrate what I mentioned in Pugilistic's thread about it being the trainer's responsibility to assure that the fighter is developing mentally as well as physically. Some of these guys I've worked with have had to make changes to their styles in general and it's very difficult to do that and feel good about it. They have to be worked in the Gym in ways that facilitate the building of their own confidence and satisfaction with the adjustments they need to make to improve.
First is Kolli's bag work. This session was a good one for two reasons, one is it alerted me to a mistake he'd been repeating that I'd seen but not paid enough heed to. Second is he was tired, and he knew he was going to struggle with form in the last round or two. Kolli's a good thinker in the ring, so what I try to do is give him ideas:
I really like that last round, because he learned the concept of bullshitting in the ring. Making it look like you're working harder than you are. A practice that suits his personality well.
Next up is Art, with two different types of bags and different reasons they're used. Art is also a thinking man, so he doesn't need to be babysat. Just basic corrections and he can run with it:
When supervising bag work with a person who has some experience it's less about repetition (repetition happens on its own, it doesn't need to be harped on), and more about what to do and when, then let them play with it. It's also how you spot thinking weaknesses in fighters. A robotic guy will just blast away at the bag over and over again. They'll naturally fall into drilling. But the drilling should facilitate technique:
The above fighter is a bit robotic in nature. The kind of kid who doesn't think deep thoughts in the middle of a task. More of a workhorse who needs to be given tools (he won't invent anything). So you gotta use drills like the above footage before you try to get him to think creatively. He'll first learn to do it out of necessity, when exhausted, when the roboticness is beaten out of him. Then you can give him more adaptive free-form exercises:
This is to demonstrate what I mentioned in Pugilistic's thread about it being the trainer's responsibility to assure that the fighter is developing mentally as well as physically. Some of these guys I've worked with have had to make changes to their styles in general and it's very difficult to do that and feel good about it. They have to be worked in the Gym in ways that facilitate the building of their own confidence and satisfaction with the adjustments they need to make to improve.