Carvel vs Cold Stone vs Baskin Robbins

[Queen B]

What do you prefer?

I like Cold Stone because they make that shit in front of you

 

[KONG-D'SNT-TAP]

All 3 suck compared to Hagen Daz.

 

[Aquabot]

I love Cold Stone but you can only do that sparingly. Cheesecake ice cream with kit kats and cookie dough is my go to mix. So damn good!

 

[Grrrr]

I prefer brusters ice cream.....cold stone out of the 3 choices you listed.

 

[ReAnimator Reagan]

What do you prefer?

I like Cold Stone because they make that shit in front of you

DQ beats them all!!!

 

[Ikuza]

I assume Ben and Jerry's is the Monica Bellucci of this tournament and was removed to make things interesting.

 

[Jesus X]

What do you prefer?

I like Cold Stone because they make that shit in front of you

I buy those milkshakes at cold stone the add peanut butter cups that are fresh AF.

 

[koolinkunming]

This thread sounds fat.

 

[minute bull]

I've only had the Carvel ice cream cake, never been to a location. Based on the chocolate on chocolate with the cookie crunch in the middle alone, Carvel wins. They got it right with the ratio of chocolate to sweet.

Coldstone is just chunky ass milkshakes you'd eat with your fingers if they didn't give you a spoon, don't kid yourself -- so that's like comparing bonafide albums to "Remastered Best Of" Retrospectives. Apples to orange-flavored sherbet.

It's hard to get bad ice cream, but once you've had something other than Baskin & Robbins, the middling quality becomes more and more conspicuous.