Television ANDOR Season 2 (Premieres April 22)

[Myrddin Wild]

The real issue is they did Luthen dirty in S2. He went from the mysterious cape with sith blades on his shuttle who had his ear to the ground and his finger in everything to a "get off my lawn" fudd who can't even keep his fooking 3 remaining employees happy lol. Andor hasn't been returning his calls, Vel is like fook this, Wilmon is doing a semester abroad in Paris while huffing paint with Saw Gerrera to forget about his thirsty farmer's daughter and even Kleya is sassing Luthen and making him look old.

That Luthen still had the means to cancel Tay Kolma's regular driver at the drop of a hat and have him replaced with Cinta for extracurricular sexy time says he's still a connected man of means and badassery. A guy that badass shouldn't have to call in his B-team guy who can't even defend a rape choke and ask him to save the MFing day twice in the same episode.

Great point.

I noticed him still working in the background but just took it as the Rebellion didn't agree with his tactics & so had to lessen his influence... and obviously not work directly with him any more than necessary.

He's been shifted to being an extremist similar to Saw, though to a lesser level of extremity. While this is understandable that Luthan sees more extreme measures that need to be tended too... (like perhaps teh blowing oop teh interrogation lab, & assassinating a top Empire supervisor) but they should've developed that contrast between the 2 methodologies a bit more.

He does seem to be on the way to castration... & will probably die in teh next ep... so lets see where this leads. Per your point, I'd like to see that contrast between teh Alliance & Luthan discussed & made clear.

Then Luthan can pull out teh light saber & lose his life in a battle against Vader~

 

[deviake]

Excellent breakdown. K2SO was originally gonna be some horror movie shit and there's character analysis about Syril

 

[ChickenBrother]

Spoiler

Haha yep. Plus she's constantly getting intel and doing A LOT of managerial stuff. Juggling plates.

That's true about Mon, and she's an important piece but there's multiple people who formed the Rebellion including other senators. I disagree with the Palpie comparison because he's from a line of Sith a millennia old who was specially chosen and is spoken of as the head of the Empire from the first movie. Mon is maybe second in command of the Rebellion at the highest but a lot of other people are at least as responsible for it's formation though she did help bankroll it from the start which of course is big.

I don't see how Cassian rescuing Mon makes him the only frontline badass nor involved in literally everything. There's waaay more going on beyond the scope of Andor not to mention he doesn't even do all the super important stuff in his own show; Luthen, Mothma, Kleya and Saw are constantly making moves, Cinta and Vel are also doing important missions in the background (Cinta saves the entire Rebellion by killing Tay), Wilmon is using his expertise, you've many others completely beyond their scope formalizing and building the Rebellion into an actual military power and establishing the base on Yavin IV, Bail Organa doing important work behind the scenes, Leia doing work, etc.

In fact if anything the show's premise is that there's a lot of important people who collectively are responsible for the fate of the galaxy, it's the opposite of the hero's journey portrayed in the movies, it exalts the boots on the ground and people working behind the scenes who are never recognized but integral. In Andor's two biggest contributions (Death Star plans, rescuing Mon) he takes part in missions that others organized and facilitated the logistics and support and they play at least an equal part. He's always shown as just one piece; he's the focus but not the most important part.

Even in the mission to rescue Mon, he would've failed without his bud's help and Kleya getting him the ID and intel and Luthen's maneuvering. I don't remember the guy's name but he was arguably more important to the mission than Andor, he found the bug and kept the Empire at bay while Andor got Mon out of there.

Edit: Oh yeah, and that's leaving on Lonni who's been providing inside intel that's been fueling the moves they've been making too.

You make good points and agree Mothma isn't comparable to Palpatine. But bruh. She's by far the most prominent OT character in Andor, so saving her has implications on SW canon.

Cassian doesn't do everything solo, but he's the guy where the rubber meets the road bashing heads to get the job done. Mechanic, intel, comms are critical too but they're service support vs. combat arms. Now Hollywood makes every job look dangerous and sexy but it was Andor and not Kleya or even Vel or Cinta who had to spend 2 days upside down in space rewiring a fighter prototype after having to escape feuding idiots in the jungle, because someone fed bad intel and then someone fucked up making sure his handoff contact was still alive. Even making it out of the hangar and escaping trained TIE fighters was James Bond shit.

Cassian seems to have been the main effort in every newsworthy rebel mission impacting the galaxy between 5 and 0 BBY.

• Aldhani heist: getaway pilot and foiled the turncoat who would have killed the others for all the money. Netted the rebellion 80 million credits which is enough to buy 500 to 1200 X-Wing fighters. Only 22 X-wings were deployed to destroy the death star in ANH.

What Could The Rebellion Spend The Credits From 'Andor' Episode 6 On? — CultureSlate

Any revolution, no matter the size, requires funding. The budding Rebellion in Andor is no exception; their money hardships were directly addressed in the series. A temporary band-aid has arrived, however, in the form of around 80 million Galactic Credits stolen from the Empire. That

www.cultureslate.com

• Ferrix massacre: he's the guy the Empire comes to apprehend. He and his BFF Brasso fuck up some Imperial shit and he rescues Bix and GTFOs out of there after Maarva's speech incites rebellion.
• Steals the first canon prototype of the TIE Interceptor, on bad intel and impeded by idiots.
• 1st round draft pick for Ghorman. Gives them the finger because he thinks they suck, disappointing Luthen who sends his B-team Vel and Cinta to get the job done. Still given 1st round preference to take out key Imperial asset there.
• After the debacle on Ghorman, goes straight to the airport for a redeye flight to rescue Mothma, aided by her mansecretary and Kleya. Kicks ass and fills the room with uppercuts.
• Steals the Death Star plans

And this is just what we've seen on the show in the annual bookend episodes of S2. Who knows WTF else he's done. And on a training budget of zero. Dude stole 80 million credits for the rebellion and they can't even pay for an online blue belt from Gracie University to teach him how to grapple. He did go K1 Andor for 5 seconds vs. Karn but still got his ass kicked by a nerd who poses souvenir spiders on his desk.

Also I'm not buying that Cinta killed Tay Kolma. I think Luthen had a talk with Kolma in the parking lot right before that scene.

 

[deviake]

You make good points and agree Mothma isn't comparable to Palpatine. But bruh. She's by far the most prominent OT character in Andor, so saving her has implications on SW canon.

Cassian doesn't do everything solo, but he's the guy where the rubber meets the road bashing heads to get the job done. Mechanic, intel, comms are critical too but they're service support vs. combat arms. Now Hollywood makes every job look dangerous and sexy but it was Andor and not Kleya or even Vel or Cinta who had to spend 2 days upside down in space rewiring a fighter prototype after having to escape feuding idiots in the jungle, because someone fed bad intel and then someone fucked up making sure his handoff contact was still alive. Even making it out of the hangar and escaping trained TIE fighters was James Bond shit.

Cassian seems to have been the main effort in every newsworthy rebel mission impacting the galaxy between 5 and 0 BBY.

• Aldhani heist: getaway pilot and foiled the turncoat who would have killed the others for all the money. Netted the rebellion 80 million credits which is enough to buy 500 to 1200 X-Wing fighters. Only 22 X-wings were deployed to destroy the death star in ANH.

What Could The Rebellion Spend The Credits From 'Andor' Episode 6 On? — CultureSlate

Any revolution, no matter the size, requires funding. The budding Rebellion in Andor is no exception; their money hardships were directly addressed in the series. A temporary band-aid has arrived, however, in the form of around 80 million Galactic Credits stolen from the Empire. That

www.cultureslate.com

• Ferrix massacre: he's the guy the Empire comes to apprehend. He and his BFF Brasso fuck up some Imperial shit and he rescues Bix and GTFOs out of there after Maarva's speech incites rebellion.
• Steals the first canon prototype of the TIE Interceptor, on bad intel and impeded by idiots.
• 1st round draft pick for Ghorman. Gives them the finger because he thinks they suck, disappointing Luthen who sends his B-team Vel and Cinta to get the job done. Still given 1st round preference to take out key Imperial asset there.
• After the debacle on Ghorman, goes straight to the airport for a redeye flight to rescue Mothma, aided by her mansecretary and Kleya. Kicks ass and fills the room with uppercuts.
• Steals the Death Star plans

And this is just what we've seen on the show in the annual bookend episodes of S2. Who knows WTF else he's done. And on a training budget of zero. Dude stole 80 million credits for the rebellion and they can't even pay for an online blue belt from Gracie University to teach him how to grapple. He did go K1 Andor for 5 seconds vs. Karn but still got his ass kicked by a nerd who arranges souvenir spiders on his desk.

Also I'm not buying that Cinta killed Tay Kolma. I think Luthen had a talk with Kolma in the parking lot right before that scene.

View attachment 1094639

That's all true but even on the things you mentioned it was never a one man show, the closest would be stealing the TIE (doesn't get anywhere near it without the help of at least multiple people). As an aside, stealing the TIE is one thing he did that I do have issue with, as he's not a trained pilot. I was fine with what they did, I get that him going into the cave and collapsing it was his hail mary that was done to explain how he got away from trained pilots but I feel like that needed a rewrite.

He gets literally nothing done without all the other elements in place, at least dozens of people with a few that we're shown being absolutely key. Even still, he's not Arnold Schwarzenegger in Commando lol. He's a part of a team that steals the Death Star plans and without a fleet showing up, a spy network, and defectors there's nothing to steal and he didn't even get those, Jyn did. Nothing moves without her and her dad.

If he didn't have an interesting story and didn't do anything noteworthy there'd be no point in the show. We may have to agree to disagree which is fine, but that's the way I see it, not to mention it's a huge galaxy with a lotta stories in it. I think they do a good job of balancing it between showing that he's a badass and giving him an interesting backstory but also showing that he's also not even close to the only important element. And it's true, who know what else he's done, but that applies to everyone else. It's a big galaxy; he didn't build the Yavin base or train an entire navy that it takes for the Rebellion to be a real force. Helping steal the Death Star plans is the only thing he's directly involved with that has anything to do with the story in the movies, the big, big time stuff and he's debatably not the MVP of that one.

The funny thing is that Kleya and Andor have a brief argument that is basically about support vs combat arms lol. She also saves the entire operation on Luthen's end by snatching that listening device. Without that one action in a show of many Mothma is had, Andor and multiple other agents are unemployed and/or captured or killed, etc and she doesn't even get that done without the mole assisting.

Lol, until I see proof otherwise I think Cinta waxed him for sure. She mentioned being in a bad accident to Vel, my guess is that she crashed the Jetson's mobile to kill him and got fucked up.

 

[ChickenBrother]

That's all true but even on the things you mentioned it was never a one man show, the closest would be stealing the TIE (doesn't get anywhere near it without the help of at least multiple people). As an aside, stealing the TIE is one thing he did that I do have issue with, as he's not a trained pilot. I was fine with what they did, I get that him going into the cave and collapsing it was his hail mary that was done to explain how he got away from trained pilots but I feel like that needed a rewrite.

He gets literally nothing done without all the other elements in place, at least dozens of people with a few that we're shown being absolutely key. Even still, he's not Arnold Schwarzenegger in Commando lol. He's a part of a team that steals the Death Star plans and without a fleet showing up, a spy network, and defectors there's nothing to steal and he didn't even get those, Jyn did. Nothing moves without her and her dad.

If he didn't have an interesting story and didn't do anything noteworthy there'd be no point in the show. We may have to agree to disagree which is fine, but that's the way I see it, not to mention it's a huge galaxy with a lotta stories in it. I think they do a good job of balancing it between showing that he's a badass and giving him an interesting backstory but also showing that he's also not even close to the only important element. And it's true, who know what else he's done, but that applies to everyone else. It's a big galaxy; he didn't build the Yavin base or train an entire navy that it takes for the Rebellion to be a real force. Helping steal the Death Star plans is the only thing he's directly involved with that has anything to do with the story in the movies, the big, big time stuff and he's debatably not the MVP of that one.

The funny thing is that Kleya and Andor have a brief argument that is basically about support vs combat arms lol. She also saves the entire operation on Luthen's end by snatching that listening device. Without that one action in a show of many Mothma is had, Andor and multiple other agents are unemployed and/or captured or killed, etc and she doesn't even get that done without the mole assisting.

Lol, until I see proof otherwise I think Cinta waxed him for sure. She mentioned being in a bad accident to Vel, my guess is that she crashed the Jetson's mobile to kill him and got fucked up.

LOL bro I'm not saying Andor is a one man show and the service support peeps don't matter. I'm saying they've had him doing too much conventional action hero stuff on every mission which strains the show's excellent writing. He's like the meme detective in a black leather jacket who does what he wants and the commissioner can't stop him because he keeps filling every room with uppercuts.

Like Vel smacks down cocky kid on Ghorman, your job isn't to think, it's to follow orders. So why doesn't that apply to Andor? All he does is backtalk and/or ignore Luthen and Kleya yet they trust him and give him full discretion on his missions. Even Imperial tactical scarface guy had to suffer the indignity of reporting to non-combatant Dedra on that mission. They should have occasionally had Cassian support another rebel badass and/or miss out on being the cowboy.

Also the only thing Cinta waxed was her pubes right before giving Tay Kolma a happy ending .....on Tahiti Prime.

 

[deviake]

LOL bro I'm not saying Andor is a one man show and the service support peeps don't matter. I'm saying they've had him doing too much conventional action hero stuff on every mission which strains the show's excellent writing. He's like the meme detective in a black leather jacket who does what he wants and the commissioner can't stop him because he keeps filling every room with uppercuts.

Like Vel admonishes cocky kid on the Ghorman heist, your job isn't to think, it's to follow orders. So why doesn't that apply to Andor? All he does is backtalk and/or ignore Luthen and Kleya yet they trust him and give him full discretion on his missions. Even Imperial tactical scarface guy had to suffer the indignity of reporting to non-combatant Dedra on that mission. They should have occasionally had Cassian support another rebel badass and/or miss out on being the cowboy.

Also the only thing Cinta waxed was her pubes right before giving Tay Kolma a happy ending .....on Tahiti Prime.

Haha well agree to disagree though I do agree about Andor supporting others from time to time but it is his show so my mind is able to override that because we don't see nearly everything he gets up to. With the time jumps Andor became a seasoned guerilla, Gilroy I believe originally wanted multiple seasons so we're relegated to these time jumps and basically a highlight reel.

If Tay makes a comeback I'll eat my shoe.









...I won't eat my shoe lol, but I know what you're saiyan, I just found it believable that he got driven to the little known planet of Merksville cuz that's how Luthen and Cinta roll. As an aside, sniping clearly isn't Andor's forte, this was foreshadowing for Rogue 1.

 

[Daverisimo]

My only complaints for episodes 7,8,9 are

1: no Saw

2: no Krennic

I hope they both have a role in the last batch.

 

[Berserker13]

 

[ChickenBrother]

Holy hell did this series deliver. Finale was perfect 10/10.

Spoiler

only let down was they didn't show Tay Kolma partying like it's 1 BBY. After Cinta introduced him to that lifestyle, I thought the ending montage would show him in the back seat of the limo with Perrin pounding Chandrilan squig with three THOTs passed out on his arm too.

 

[deviake]

Watching Rogue One after this. My god, Andor is so good. I don't rewatch things much but I will be rewatching the whole thing.

 

[Myrddin Wild]

Spoiler

I waz expecting more fireworks for teh finale, but now I enjoy them putting their big climax in teh 3rd block & then tying everything oop in the final block.

At first I wondered if Luthan's final act was even valuable to the story, but re-watching Rogue One... they were able to track Jyn Erso down in the time it took Cassa to talk to the source that had over-heard the pilot Galen sent the message with. If they had to talk to the source first & then track down Jyn, it would've been too late to see the hologram from Saw & for her to talk to her dad.

I thought it would've been fun if Daedra turned on teh empire after they sent her into a war zone where her boy toy died. I mean, they could've given them a heads oop at the least. This waz pretty satisfying seeing her end oop in a similar production prison that Andy was in though.

I feel like teh first ep of the final block (& to some degree the 2nd) could've been shortened to make room for Galen sending his message with that pilot, but it's all good.

Wow, what an ending!!! I thought they were foreshadowing Bix dying when Andy was talking about walking away from the Rebels, & her death would bring him back, but this was much more satisfying.

Would be cool AF to tie teh child into the Skywalker Saga later as a teen somehow. Perhaps he was one of the kids with Jedi powers that Luke was training prior to Kylo burning them all.

I do like the idea that Andy waz a regular guy though... but they could do something with him. Teh timeline from Teh Manalorian until the Sequelz is pretty wide open.

Watching Rogue One after this. My god, Andor is so good. I don't rewatch things much but I will be rewatching the whole thing.

& then after that, go straight into A New Hope.

I saw Rogue One in teh theater opening weekend, & came straight home to watch a New Hope. Even though that waz like the hundredth time I had watched it, everything took on such a new meaning. That waz masterfully done.