Almost the end of 2020, Top 3 in all weight classes all time. Go!

[JustOnce]

Heavyweight

1. Fedor
2. Stipe
3. Werdum

Light heavyweight

1. Jones
2. Shogun
3. DC

Middleweight

1. Android
2. Hendo
3. Romero

Welterweight

1.GSP
2.Usman?
3.Hughes

Lightweight

1.Gomi
2.Khabib
3. BJ

FW

1. Aldo
2. Edgar
3. Conor

BW

1. Cruz
2. Cejudo
3. Dillsnake

FW

1.DJ
2.Fig
3.Horiguchi

 

[Zebra Cheeks]

Heavyweight

1. Fedor
2. Stipe
3. Werdum

Light heavyweight

1. Jones
2. Shogun
3. DC

Middleweight

1. Android
2. Hendo
3. Romero

Welterweight

1.GSP
2.Usman?
3.Hughes

Lightweight

1.Gomi
2.Khabib
3. BJ

FW

1. Aldo
2. Edgar
3. Conor

BW

1. Cruz
2. Cejudo
3. Dillsnake

FW

1.DJ
2.Fig
3.Horiguchi

How is Edgar ranked above Holloway at 145?

 

[JustOnce]

How is Edgar ranked above Holloway at 145?

Fair point. I like edgar more

 

[Zebra Cheeks]

Fair point. I like edgar more

Fair enough. What about dillishaw below cejudo?

 

[GangGangGang]

Why does everyone have Hendo so high up on their MW GOAT lists? Hes a top 5 favorite fighter of all time for me but the guy was much more a 205er than a 185er. Think he has 2 top 10 wins at 185 in his career and a overall record of 8-6.

 

[Zebra Cheeks]

Why does everyone have Hendo so high up on their MW GOAT lists? Hes a top 5 favorite fighter of all time for me but the guy was much more a 205er than a 185er. Think he has 2 top 10 wins at 185 in his career and a overall record of 8-6.

Because historically LHW is much deeper, and his fans want to put him somewhere

 

[cade187]

Romero is not #3. It’s probably Izzy tbh and I don’t even like him.

I agree with your top 3 LW, but the order is wrong.

Khabib, Penn, Gomi

 

[Bend NvR Break]

I'll bite

HW - Fedor, Stipe, Overeem

LHW - Jon, DC, Wand

MW - Silva, Izzy, Franklin

WW - GSP, Hughes, Woodley

LW - BJ, Khabib, Benson

FW - Aldo, McGregor, Holloway

BW - Cruz, Faber, Barao

FlyW - MM, Cejudo, IDC

 

[Streeter]

I'll bite

HW - Fedor, Stipe, Overeem

LHW - Jon, DC, Wand

MW - Silva, Izzy, Franklin

WW - GSP, Hughes, Woodley

LW - BJ, Khabib, Benson

FW - Aldo, McGregor, Holloway

BW - Cruz, Faber, Barao

FlyW - MM, Cejudo, IDC

 

[JustOnce]

I'll bite

HW - Fedor, Stipe, Overeem

LHW - Jon, DC, Wand

MW - Silva, Izzy, Franklin

WW - GSP, Hughes, Woodley

LW - BJ, Khabib, Benson

FW - Aldo, McGregor, Holloway

BW - Cruz, Faber, Barao

FlyW - MM, Cejudo, IDC

BENDO

 

[Zebra Cheeks]

Heavyweight

1. Fedor
2. Stipe
3. Werdum

Light heavyweight

1. Jones
2. Shogun
3. DC

Middleweight

1. Android
2. Hendo
3. Romero

Welterweight

1.GSP
2.Usman?
3.Hughes

Lightweight

1.Gomi
2.Khabib
3. BJ

FW

1. Aldo
2. Edgar
3. Conor

BW

1. Cruz
2. Cejudo
3. Dillsnake

FW

1.DJ
2.Fig
3.Horiguchi

HW Fedor, Stipe, Werdum
Lhw Jones, wanderlai, Chuck
MW Anderson, weidman, far off in third is Izzy
WW GSP, Hughes, Usman
LW Khabib, Bj, Bendo
FW: Aldo, McGregor, Holloway
BW: Cruz, dillishaw, cejudo
Flyweight: DJ, Cejudo, Fig

 

[Sweater of AV]

Weight-classes are for the weak.

Fedor
Saku
Big Nog
BJ
Hendo

 

[Tyrannosaurus rex]

HW: Fedor, Stipe, Werdum
LHW: Jones, DC, Wanderlei
MW: Anderson, Adesanya, Whittaker
WW: GSP, Hughes, Usman
LW: Khabib, Penn, Gomi
FW: Aldo, Holloway, McGregor
BW: Cruz, Dillashaw, Barao
FLW: DJ, Cejudo, Figueiredo

WFW: Cyborg, Nunes, nobody else of note
WBW: Nunes, Ronda, Holm
WFLW: Shevchenko, nobody else of note
WSW: Joanna, Zhang, Rose

 

[AladdinSane]

Hw Cheick Kongo, Matt Mittrione, Tank Abbott


Lhw: matt Hamill, Brandon vera, and James Irvin

Mw Patrick cote, Costa Phillipou, and Chael Sonnet

WW. Brian ebersole Paul Daley, and Chris lytle

 

[Sad Dad]

Heavyweight

1. Fedor
2. Stipe
3. Werdum

Light heavyweight

1. Jones
2. Shogun
3. DC

Middleweight

1. Android
2. Hendo
3. Romero

Welterweight

1.GSP
2.Usman?
3.Hughes

Lightweight

1.Gomi
2.Khabib
3. BJ

FW

1. Aldo
2. Edgar
3. Conor

BW

1. Cruz
2. Cejudo
3. Dillsnake

FW

1.DJ
2.Fig
3.Horiguchi

Romero over rob and Izzy really? Lol

 

[BOTTICELLI]

I'll bite

HW - Fedor, Stipe, Overeem

LHW - Jon, DC, Wand

MW - Silva, Izzy, Franklin

WW - GSP, Hughes, Woodley

LW - BJ, Khabib, Benson

FW - Aldo, McGregor, Holloway

BW - Cruz, Faber, Barao

FlyW - MM, Cejudo, IDC

This is the closest list to mine. Almost identical

 

[mkw]

HW: Fedor, Stipe, Cain
LHW: Jones, DC, Chuck
MW: Anderson, Israel, Weidman
WW: GSP, Hughes, Shields
LW: Khabib, BJ, Frankie
FW: Aldo, Conor, Max
BW: Cruz, Barao, TJ
FLY: DJ, Cejudo, Joe B (will be replaced by Fig after next defense)
WFW: Cyborg, Amanda, Gina
WBW: Amanda, Ronda, Val
WFLY: Val
WSW: JJ, Rose, Weili

 

[JustOnce]

Romero over rob and Izzy really? Lol

Romero > Rob

Izzy ran like Kalib Starnes possessed

 

[ferrisjso]

Heavyweight

1. Fedor
2. Stipe
3. Werdum

Light heavyweight

1. Jones
2. Shogun
3. DC

Middleweight

1. Android
2. Hendo
3. Romero

Welterweight

1.GSP
2.Usman?
3.Hughes

Lightweight

1.Gomi
2.Khabib
3. BJ

FW

1. Aldo
2. Edgar
3. Conor

BW

1. Cruz
2. Cejudo
3. Dillsnake

FW

1.DJ
2.Fig
3.Horiguchi

HW
No order arguments for all
Werdum, DC,Stipe

LHW
1.Jones
2.Machida
3.Gustafsson

MW
1.Weidman, Izzy
3.AS

WW
1.GSP
2.Marty
3.Shields or Fitch

LW
1.Khabib
2.Tony
3.Dustin(yes I think this lowly of the reign of previous LW champs)

FW
1.Volk
2.Max
3.Aldo

BW
I honestly don't have an opinion on this because the best BW's fought the same guys over and over.

FLW
1.MM
2.Joe B
3.Cjuedo

 

[bufetadanacara]

Heavyweight

1. Fedor
2. Nogueira
3. Stipe


Light heavyweight

1. Wanderlei
2. Shogun
3. Liddell


Middleweight

1. Anderson
2. Hendo
3. Bustamante


Welterweight

1.GSP
2.Hughes
3.Usman

Lightweight

1.Penn
2.Khabib
3. Gomi