Can Julianna Pēna Become A WMMA GOAT?

[pcbh167]

If she beats Amanda again in the rematch and then beats Valentina, would that make her a WMMA GOAT?

I know some of you guys have said stuff like Amanda is going to beat her in rematch and that Valentina could become double champ by fighting Pēna.
However, ‘IF’ Pēna were to beat them would that make her a GOAT?

Valentina and Amanda are considered to be WMMA GOATS. Pena just took one of them out when they were on a 12 fight win streak. If she does it again and takes out the other one then that would be incredible.

 

[Benoitthegr8]

<{cruzshake}>

 

[JonJonesNeedle]

Julianna Pena is already the WMMA GOAT

 

[Simple Southerner]

Enough goat talk ffs just let them bang

 

[pcbh167]

View attachment 902744

Enough goat talk ffs just let them bang

I agree, but I’ve had to hear about Valentina and Amanda being GOAT’s for the past few years. Lol Seems like the GOAT talk is never going to stop; in which case it would be amazing if Pēna were to be considered a GOAT too.
Especially since so many people thought Amanda was going to destroy her and she was the dark horse of the division before that.

 

[Sweater of AV]

Can? Sure. Will? No.

 

[Ancient Warrior]

Only Shang Tsung can take a victims soul.

You don’t gain a fighters entire legacy when you beat them. Nunes is a big win but she’s just won the title. Gives us a call again when she’s at least made several defenses.

 

[Fahcough]

She could be the Jimmy Washington of the Olympics

 

[Dreyga Hates You Sherbums]

Nah. Even if she beats Amanda…Holly or Aldana will take the belt from her

 

[Gamer007]

Fan since tuf days, no.

 

[WingzOfRedemption]

Greatest mom of all time

 

[Fergelmince]

She's been submitted too many times by.......STRIIKERS

 

[Pierced7681]

Holly waxes her imo

 

[sabretitan]

Lol no

 

[pcbh167]

Only Shang Tsung can take a victims soul.

You don’t gain a fighters entire legacy when you beat them. Nunes is a big win but she’s just won the title. Gives us a call again when she’s at least made several defenses.

That’s what I’m saying. If she defends her title a few more times and has 2 wins over Nunes and a win over Valentina. That would be amazing because for the past few years those two fighters have been the cream of the crop

 

[Post 2 Decision]

No. There's no one for her to beat that will put her over. If she beats a smaller woman in Shevchenko, sure whatever, but Ronda and Cyborg are gone. Nunes has wins over all 3.

 

[kingghidrah]

she has to beat Amanda and then get one more win and she is easily the undisputed GOAT, and I mean like, the all-time greatest GOAT, not just a run of the mill GOAT

 

[pcbh167]

No. There's no one for her to beat that will put her over. If she beats a smaller woman in Shevchenko, sure whatever, but Ronda and Cyborg are gone. Nunes has wins over all 3.

Nunes did beat all 3; so the fact that Pēna beat her and finished her should put her over IMO. Especially if she beats her again and Valentina has been looking unstoppable these past few years. If Valentina’s size takes away from your legacy then we should discredit Amanda’s two wins against her too because she was way bigger than her.
Also, Pēna has actually fought at 125 a few times so it’s not like she’s that much bigger than her. Amanda is a natural 145er though.

 

[aerius]

Let me answer your question with another question: Is Chris Weidman in the GOAT conversation?

 

[Post 2 Decision]

Nunes did beat all 3; so the fact that Pēna beat her and finished her should put her over IMO. Especially if she beats her again and Valentina has been looking unstoppable these past few years. If Valentina’s size takes away from your legacy then we should discredit Amanda’s two wins against her too because she was way bigger than her.
Also, Pēna has actually fought at 125 a few times so it’s not like she’s that much bigger than her. Amanda is a natural 145er though.

If you beat someone you don't get credit for all of their wins, that's ludicrous.

And I wasn't discrediting a win over Shevchenko.
Shevchenko beat Nunes anyway.