After seeing your doom videos I’m surprised to see only 2 mentioned and it being that far down on the list.
I only listed doom( but I meant the whole series as a whole, without picking a specific one).
Same way I listed ME, even though 1 is my favorite.
The Last of Us
The entire Uncharted series
Assassin's creed 2
Skyrim
Fallout: New Vegas
Tough one. Probably go at time of writing with:
Final Fantasy VI
Bloodborne
Secret of Evermore
Dark Souls
Flashback
The Last of Us
Grand Theft Auto V
Grand Theft Auto: Vice City
L.A. Noire
Red Dead Redemption
Replayability is a huge factor for me. Technically speaking DOOM (2016) is a masterwork in graphics and audio design and artistically as well. But the MP was mediocre. The campaign was not one that was to memorable with great level design and again it doesn't have a lot to bring me back. Definitely a great game but not an all time fave.