Penny Hardaway, Grant Hill, or Tracy McGrady? Who would you take fully healthy?

[Fedorgasm]

McGrady is the worst of the 3 IMO. He may have scored the most points, but that happens when you're the best scorer on terrible teams.

Penny was better. At least he had a good basketball IQ and would get his teammates involved.

Grant Hill is by far the best of the 3. He could score, pass, play defense, and had the best IQ of all of them. Unselfish player that got his teammates involved and was better at winning games than padding his own stats.

 

[Lord Commander Palis]

Pretty crazy Snaq had Penny and Tracy but couldn't win. Then goes to the Lakers and plays with a true all time great shooting guard and all of a sudden wins.

Just goes to show how much better Kobe truly is vs 99.9% of all NBA players.

 

[Prefect]

Pretty crazy Snaq had Penny and Tracy but couldn't win. Then goes to the Lakers and plays with a true all time great shooting guard and all of a sudden wins.

Just goes to show how much better Kobe truly is vs 99.9% of all NBA players.

Shaq never played with McGrady. The Magic were a legit team with Shaq, Penny, Anderson, Grant, Skiles, and Scott. They would likely have won had they had a few more years or didn't coincide with Hakeem having a ridiculous couple of years.

 

[Lord Commander Palis]

Shaq never played with McGrady. The Magic were a legit team with Shaq, Penny, Anderson, Grant, Skiles, and Scott. They would likely have won had they had a few more years or didn't coincide with Hakeem having a ridiculous couple of years.

Ahh ya that's right. Got him and Andersen mixed up as McGrady came right after

 

[Ceez]

Those magic teams for sure would have won a title or two if Penny stayed healthy which you can't say about these other guys.

You mean if shaq stayed, your argument is irelevant..thats like saying i wouldnt have went to jail if i didnt committ that crime jesus christ

You put Tmac with Shaq and he wins titles, im not so sure about G Hill but imo TMac would have done some damage with shaq. Dude carried shit teams on his back in the yoffs and was better in the yoffs than the regular season.

 

[the ambush]

Grant Hill and fully healthy would be an anomaly and never quite went together.

To answer the question Hill or McGrady and then Hardaway.

 

[Gio]

Grant Hill is Lebron before Lebron. He's putting up Lebron like stats before he got injured. It was just not given much attention coz there's a guy out there named Michael Jordan and his Bulls dominating the league that time

 

[lifelessheap]

Tmac via suit.

 

[Stargazer Rex]

Tmac via suit.

Is that a Steve Harvey suit?

 

[Stargazer Rex]

Grant Hill

 

[Naramie]

 

[dutch18022]

We seen the best T-Mac. Injuries didn’t keep us from seeing who he is. Leading scorer of the league. Team finished terrible

 

[xcvbn]

Grant Hills sneakers were cool



So were the air Pennies

The TMac 3's were hella comfortable. Rocked em on the 8th grade team.

 

[TankAbbott4Eva]

Penny Hardaway could have been one of the GOATs imo so i'm saying him.

 

[gopackgo555]

Derrick Rose then T mac

 

[lifelessheap]

Grant Hill if he didn't get derailed.....

 

[Shaungotti]

All great players, no doubt. To me I'd take a healthy Grant Hill without hesitation.

 

[Furious77]

I'm really suprised i don't see more people saying Hill. He was a legit projected to be one of the greats. I love T-mac offensive game but scoring is all you were going to get from him. Penny was talented but I never got that leadership vibe that you got from the greats. The funny thing is after all these guys were hampered by injuries G. Hill was the most effective just from a fundamental and basketball iq standpoint. This isn't even close to me.

 

[Furious77]

Pretty crazy Snaq had Penny and Tracy but couldn't win. Then goes to the Lakers and plays with a true all time great shooting guard and all of a sudden wins.

Just goes to show how much better Kobe truly is vs 99.9% of all NBA players.

Im a kobe fan but that Magic team that Shaq took to the finals was young and inexperieiced. It's not really fair to say he wouldn't have won a finals, because he most likely would have if he stayed. Shaq didn't win right away in LA either, so not really a fair comparison. Also I don't think Mcgrady even played with Shaq.

 

[Furious77]

T-Mac - dude was a beast.

On offense only. Hill beasted everywhere and made his teammates better.