Is Georges St-Pierre the greatest of all time?

[Shabutie]

Yes

 

[eddymotto]

eyeball test... Jones followed by Fedor.

But Jones hasn't ben able to stay active enough and has been caught cheating twice now. Even if you don't care about PEDs, it is a problem because you can't build a fight resume sitting at home

Silva - PED problem

so overall probably Fedor vs. GSP. Fedor had greater peak IMO. GSP never had the big fall off late in career (so far).

 

[markg171]

For all of you GSP dickriders

http://forums.sherdog.com/threads/your-fighter´s-goat.3730621/

Thought some might like a count as opposed to the jumbled mess.

Fedor: 37
Silva: 36
Jones: 29
GSP: 16

A poll done 2 years ago isn't really relevant, when GSP went on to win his second belt, Jon defeated DC to win his 3rd, Anderson beat a top 10 fighter, and Fedor got KO'd.